Science Questions

The Naked Scientists: Science Radio & Science Podcasts

Science Questions RSS Feed

Do copper cures and magnetic medicine work?

Can copper bracelets relieve the pain of arthritis, and do magnets have healing properties? Hazel Smith and William

Kat -   The answer to the magnet question is, no.  There’s absolutely no evidence that magnets have healing properties.  It’s all a scam.  In terms of copper bracelets, there’s a lot of old wives’ tales about copper bracelets and when they’ve been investigated for arthritis, again, the scientific studies don’t actually show any significant benefit.  There may be psychological benefit.  The placebo effect as we know is extremely powerful, but no.  There’s no real scientific evidence.

July 2009

- hazel smith - 28th Apr 09
- JimBob - 28th Apr 09
- Don_1 - 29th Apr 09
- dentstudent - 29th Apr 09
- tangoblue - 30th Apr 09
- _Stefan_ - 30th Apr 09
- stereologist - 11th May 09
- rosy - 8th Jul 09
- morkelkey - 30th Jul 09
- Don_1 - 30th Jul 09
- Chemistry4me - 31st Jul 09
- vickywatts - 14th Sep 10
- Fozzie - 17th Sep 10
- Geezer - 17th Sep 10
- RD - 18th Sep 10
That is interesting and  something new to my reading.. I had never heard about the gold..LOL Copper bracelets have been around for years.. my Aunt Swore by them I find no relief whatsoever wearing them in my arthritic hands. Although I must say my hand with my ring is good particularly my wedding ring finger.. so I find this interesting.
- Karen W. - 20th Sep 10


Anecdotal "evidence" is not really of much scientific value, but nor is dogma.

In my mid-40s I developed quite severe osteoarthritis, various prescribed medications had no effect.  My wife bought me a copper bracelet; I agreed to try it for 3 months, not expecting any benefit.  By the end of the 3 months I was pain free.  A doctor with whom I was working at the time told me that I was almost certainly "in remission".  I am now 70, and still "in remission".  Of course, this proves nothing, but my advice to anyone in the position I was in would be: never mind the prophets of gloom, "give it a go", make up your own mind if it works for you.
- Bill S - 9th Dec 10
Your body would likely absorb small amounts of copper from the bracelet...  does your arm turn green?  Some people have nickel allergies to nickel alloys so metals in jewelery will affect your body.

But, for many things, some people will go into spontaneous remission....  and then one has to try to figure out if it was a therapy or not that caused it.  There are many causes of joint pain.  Was it a single joint?  All Joints?  Gout?

Here is an article review that discusses a randomized trial disproving magnetic therapy and copper therapy.  It doesn't support any efficacy claims.  I believe trial periods were for 4 weeks in each case or trial condition.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/10/091016094037.htm

However, if the copper bracelet has been helping the arthritis for 30 years, by all means keep it up.
- CliffordK - 10th Dec 10
See the whole discussion | Make a comment



Naked Scientists Science Radio Show Home Who are The Naked Scientists Information about Naked Scientists
Naked Scientists Podcast Ask the Naked Scientists Podcast Question of the Week Podcast
Naked Science Articles Experiments to do at Home Science Discussion Forum
Science News Stories Answers to Science Questions Interviews with Famous Scientists

Information presented on this website is the opinion of the individual contributors and does not reflect the general views of the administrators, editors, moderators, sponsors, Cambridge University or the public at large.

Click here for the Naked Scientists PODCAST

The contents of this site are © The Naked Scientists® 2000-2012. The Naked Scientists® and Naked Science® are registered trademarks.