
|
Is the Earth getting heavier?Is the Earth getting heavier? As the human population grows, are we putting on weight as a planet?
David Hubble, US |

|
Chris - Yes but perhaps not for the reason that he was suggesting. People often think that as we increase our population the weight of the people comes from nowhere. People just weigh more and the Earth therefore weighs more. That's not true. The Earth is a sealed unit where all the of the weight that was on it to start with doesn't go anywhere. You don't make weight from nowhere so people have got to gain weight by taking weight from elsewhere on the Earth. Eating food that's come out of the Earth into their bodies. The planet as a whole, does that get heavier over time? The answer is yes, it can. Every year Earth gains about the weight of two aircraft carriers landing on it – two HMS Ark Royals. 40,000 tonnes-worth of debris lands on Earth. You can demonstrate this for yourself. If you put a big plastic sheet or a white sheet on your grass in the garden on a nice day, leave it for a few hours and then run a magnet over it. You can often find specks have just fallen down from outer space and landed on your magnet. Debris, dust and other stuff raining in from space contributes a huge amount of weight to the Earth every single year. Yes, we do gain weight. |
|
October 2008 |
David Hubbell asked the Naked Scientists:
Is the Earth getting heavier, With population growth? Will the Earth continue to get heavier and heavier, as the population continues to increase? Does this increased weight, affect the Earth's gravitational pull and centrifugal force ?
Thank you, I find your show fun and informative.
David
Oregon,USA
What do you think?
- David Hubbell - 1st Oct 08
No. Matter can neither be created nor destroyed. Each individual must consume food & water in order to grow. What we eat is either used for the growth of our bodies, energy to power them, then passed out as waste or passed straight through as waste. The total weight of our bodies cannot exceed that which we put in.
- Don_1 - 2nd Oct 08
Don_1 is spot on but you could argue that if the loss of atmosphere to space has stopped then the Earth is getting imperceptibly heavier with the arrival of meteorites and other interstellar stuff that lands here.
- blakestyger - 2nd Oct 08
Yes, you could take the weight of such interstellar bodies and subtract the weight of space probes sent out by man, never to return, to arrive at a figure. But as you say it would be so infinitesimal by comparison to the weight of the planet as to be as to be imperceivable.
- Don_1 - 2nd Oct 08
See the whole discussion | Make a comment |
|
|