Question of the Week

The Naked Scientists: Science Radio & Science Podcasts

Science Questions RSS Feed

Does snow cool the world by reflecting light?

I've read that painting rooftops white can help to cool cities. So does ploughing away the snow warm the earth up and add to global warming? Jacob, USA

We put this question to John King from the British Antarctic Survey in Cambridge:

John -   Well, the thing about snow is that it’s quite reflective compared to bare ground.  A good thick snow cover will reflect back up to 80 percent or even more of the sunlight that’s falling on it.  Whereas bare ground or grasslands might only reflect 10 or 20 percent of the sunlight falling on it and so, the sunlight warms it up considerably.  A snow covered Bodträsk railway station, Kalix kommun, SwedenSo, if you replace that bare ground by snow cover, then a lot of the sunlight that would’ve heated the ground just gets reflected back into space.  So, if you remove a snow cover by ploughing it up or sweeping it away or whatever, revealing the bare ground underneath, then the ground is going to absorb a lot more sunlight, and will warm up a lot more quickly than if the snow were there.  We are having an effect on the reflectivity, the albedo of the planet by changing land use for instance; cutting down forests and replacing them with grasslands.  But that generally has the opposite effect, forests absorb quite a lot of sunlight, grassland is less reflective.  People have suggested that we could partially offset global warming by painting the roofs of all of our buildings white.  I think some calculations have been done that have showed that this will be a good thing, but it wouldn’t have a very large effect because you're only talking about a rather small area of the planet that you'll be changing the reflectivity of.

February 2010

Hello:
This is John Berger writing from Canada, not far from the warmest winter Olympics ever.
I'm in the home repair business, and one way of quickly determining whether a home's insulation is adequate or not is to see how quickly snow melts from its roof. If the attic insulation is inadequate, snow will melt more quickly on that roof than from those of the neighbouring homes, thus leaking heat to the environment.
Similarly, snow is an excellent insulator, being an icy equivalent of fibre-glass batts we press into walls and ceilings. Therefore, removing snow from the roof is similar to removing insulation from the attic. With flat roofs, some people haul up a snow-blower machine to speed the job. Most snow-blowers are gasoline fueled, and thus add to the green house gas volume.
Finally, if the snow on the roof is heavy enough to cause the roof to collapse, and you consider the energy needed to rebuild the roof, then green-house gases will be generated via transporting new building materials and manufacturing asphalt shingles, etc.
Hope this answers the question.
John Berger
Nanaimo BC Canada
- diverjohn - 17th Feb 10


→ Floods reduce source of anthropogenic warming  → equilibrium is restored 



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryosphere
- RD - 18th Feb 10
Yes, the impact of ice and snow reflections have been appreciated for a long while. This is why an ice-age is a positive feedback loop: more snow and ice means more energy reflected back into space, which means a cooler planet, which means more snow and ice and so on. What arrests - and reverses - these processes though, I'm not sure.

Milankovitch cycles, which are long-term (120,000 year cyclical) periodic warming and cooling episodes, are linked to a range of planetary factors including precession, tilt wobble and orbit eccentricity. These changes alters solar energy input, affecting global temperatures. The huge amount of energy already stored in the system means that there is inertia, so changes occur gradually.

Chris
- chris - 18th Feb 10
Hello Guys,

Yes absolutely snow can not pass light to pass through it and reflect it back.

Thanks
Mark.
- Mark Lehman - 29th Apr 10
See the whole discussion | Make a comment



Naked Scientists Science Radio Show Home Who are The Naked Scientists Information about Naked Scientists
Naked Scientists Podcast Ask the Naked Scientists Podcast Question of the Week Podcast
Naked Science Articles Experiments to do at Home Science Discussion Forum
Science News Stories Answers to Science Questions Interviews with Famous Scientists

Information presented on this website is the opinion of the individual contributors and does not reflect the general views of the administrators, editors, moderators, sponsors, Cambridge University or the public at large.

Click here for the Naked Scientists PODCAST

The contents of this site are © The Naked Scientists® 2000-2012. The Naked Scientists® and Naked Science® are registered trademarks.