Podcast Transcript

The Naked Scientists: Science Radio & Science Podcasts

Superhero 3D X-ray vision

Memories Survive Metamorphosis

Despite dramatic changes in every aspect of their biology, it seems that moths and butterflies can remember things they learned as caterpillars.

Tobacco Hornworm CaterpillarCaterpillars can be thought of as eating machines - as they do very little but eat to store up they energy they will need when they form a chrysalis.  During metamorphosis, as they become a butterfly or moth, they undergo a radical change in body plan as well as lifestyle and diet.  The change is so dramatic that it had been assumed that memories or associations learned during the larval, or caterpillar period would be lost to the adult stage.

Writing in the March issue of PLoS One, Doug Blackiston and colleagues at Georgetown university trained tobacco hornworm caterpillars to avoid certain odours by associating the smell with an electric shock.  After metamorphosis, the adult moths also avoided the odours, showing they had retained the association despite huge changes in physiology.

Tobacco Hornworm MothHowever, the ability to retain these memories depended on when they were learned - Caterpillars younger that three weeks old could learn to avoid the odour, but did not retain the memory into adulthood.  In those caterpillars conditioned shortly before pupation, the memories survived the pupal stage and were demonstrated in the adult.  

Retaining memories from before metamorphosis could allow female butterflies to lay her eggs on the same type of host plant that she fed on during her larval stage.  This 'habitat selection' could lead to the development of new sub species of butterfly.

9th Mar 2008


Mysterious Forces

For the last 10 years physicists have been puzzled by a mysterious force acting on space probes. There have been various slight anomalies detected in how spacecraft move which don't seem to be moving quite as we would predict them to.

One of the first anomalies was noticed on the pioneer spacecraft that visited the outer solar system in the 1970s and are still heading off into space. They seem to be slowing down slightly faster than we would predict using our present understanding of physics. This effect is minute, about a ten billionth as strong as the force of gravity on the surface of the earth but it is measurable. This effect could just be due to some physics we already understand, like a gas leak or we don't understand how the probe is radiating heat.

GalileoNow a team from the jet propulsion laboratory in California have found another anomaly which seems to appear when some spacecraft make a flyby of earth. For examble when the NEAR spacecraft flew past the earth on its way to visit an asteroid, it left moving at 13mm/s slower than it should have done, and the Galileo probe was speeded up by 4mm/s these are tiny effects as the probes are moving more than a million times faster than this, but it is well within our ability to measure their speeds.

Some probes have this effect and others don't, Frank Jordan who is part of the team which was looking at this effect and trying formulae to try and model these results and found one that works nicely. It seems to suggest that probes which approach and leave the earth at a similar angle to the equator won't feel an effect, but probes which enter and leave at different angles feel this strange extra force.

This doesn't say anything about what could be causing the force, but the fact that the equator is important could indicate that the earth's rotation is affecting it somehow. Einstein's theory of general relativity suggests some effects related to rotating massive objects, but they should be much smaller than this, so it is just possible that these may be some hints at some interesting new physics.


9th Mar 2008


Water-Guzzlers

Running vehicles on alternatives to fossil fuels could stress scarce water resources, US scientists have warned.

Drought - Sonora Desert, MexicoMichael Webber and Carey King, from the University of Texas at Austin, suggest that powering America's cars with electricity, rather than gasoline (petrol), could triple the nation's water consumption. And biofuels, derived from crops requiring irrigation, are even more water-intensive, according to a further unpublished analysis by the team.

 'This doesn't mean that we shouldn't try to switch to alternative fuels - but if we're going to do it, we need to be aware of a potential downside,' Webber explains.

Increased evaporation

Water is the main coolant in the coal, gas, or nuclear power plants that largely supply vehicles with electricity. Webber and Carey calculate that when switching from 'gasoline miles' to 'electric miles', approximately three times more water is evaporated into the atmosphere, and seventeen times more water withdrawn for cycling around the plant before being returned to a river or lake.

While parts of the US are water-rich, limited water availability in some drought-stricken areas (such as the south-east) might hinder the growth of power plant systems that would be needed to cope with the greater demand by electric vehicles, says Webber.

He recommends switching to less water-intensive methods of generating energy: for example, solar or wind power; using non-irrigated biofuels; or using reclaimed or salt water to cool power plants.

Neglected link

Peter Gleick, president of the environmental think-tank the Pacific Institute in Oakland, California, thinks that the added water demands Webber identifies may not be very significant. 'In regions where water is scarce, the key will be to produce fuels, or electricity, where water is less of a constraint,' he said.

But both Webber and Gleick feel that the link between water and energy has been neglected amid understandable concerns about security and carbon-costs of energy supplies. 'We've typically considered water and energy separately, and it is no longer appropriate to do so. We can no longer push for energy policies that ignore our water challenges, just as we can't push for water policies that ignore energy costs and benefits,' Gleick said.

Richard Van Noorden

9th Mar 2008


The Smell of the Reef

Phytoplankton and algae living on coral reefs release a chemical which attracts fish from miles around, and could play a key role in reef ecology.

Reef fishEcosystems are all about balance, and the phytoplankton have an ingenious way to keep things in check.  Phytoplankton are similar to plants, they harvest energy from sunlight using chlorophyll, and are a vital part of the ocean ecosystem.  Zooplankton also play a vital role, including feeding on the phytoplankton.  Jennifer DeBose and colleagues at the University of California at Davis have shown that in response to being grazed by zooplankton, phytoplankton release a chemical, Dimethylsulfoniopropionate (DMSP), which attracts fish which feed on zooplankton.

DeBose and team tested the hypothesis at different reefs by releasing either DMSP or distilled water from special tanks and found over four times as many fish attracted to the DMSP plumes.

Their findings suggest that planktivorous fish, those that eat plankton, have developed a way to 'eavesdrop' on the interactions between phyto- and zooplankton to help find good food resources.

9th Mar 2008


Can you get moonbows?

I was driving home one night, six weeks ago. There was a full moon and it was a beautiful clear night. There was just a bit of rain coming in from the west. I had to put my windscreen wipers on and it was making a horrible smear across my screen. What I saw at first I thought was muck from the road smearing across my screen, there was this light crescent in the sky. I put my windscreen washers on and it cleared away yet this thing was still there. What I was looking at was basically a very precise, very thin crescent of what looked like light in the sky. I thought it might be clouds or something and then it came to me: it's a moonlight rainbow. Is this actually possible, and if it is, how does it happen? Sam Smith

Dave: Was the moon behind you or in front of you?

Sam: It was in front of me and I was going into the rain.

Lunar RainbowDave: I think that is a straight moonbow. It's exactly the same as a rainbow caused by the sun so what happens is, if you shine light on a droplet of water the light will bounce around inside it and when it comes out different colours will come out in different directions. So if you look at different places you'll see a rainbow. The moon is a source of essentially white light so you'll get exactly the same effect. Because it's so dim your eyes won't be sensitive to the colour so you just see a bow of brightness rather than a colour. If you took a very long exposure photograph of it or you had an image intensifier which worked in colours then you would be able to see the colours and it would look just like a normal rainbow.

Sam: I was looking them up afterwards to see if I was imagining things. It seems they're quite rare.

Dave: Yes, proper rainbows are. Normally people just see a ring around the moon itself, maybe 20-30 degrees outside the moon which is normally created by little ice particles. It isn't a true rainbow, it's a similar sort of effect.

March 2008


Why does milk change colour when it freezes?

My son Robert has been wondering about this question: when we freeze milk it changes colour – from white to yellow. Why is this? Paul Dart

The reason for this is that milk isn't just a straightforward solution, it's not like dissolving salt in water.  Milk is what's called an emulsion.  It's a mixture of various things which are suspended in water.  Milk is about 5% fat and that fat is dispersed through the water as tiny globules.  They're cells and surrounded by little proteins.  They have a fat-loving part of the protein and a water-loving end.  The fat loving part of the protein sticks into the fat and the water-loving bit sticks into the water.  This helps to solubalise or keep suspended the fat molecules.  Also in the milk are these things called pepsinogens or proteins because milk contains a lot of protein.

The idea of milk is to nourish a growing animal and protein is what you need to grow more muscle and get bigger.  When you put your milk in the freezer all these things which are normally well-suspended and kept separate begin to become very close together.  The freezing process means that the water in the milk, 95% forms big chunky ice crystals and they don't want to have the proteins and the fat in them.  The proteins and the fat get squeezed out of the mixture.  They tend to form around this central core of ice.  So because you see all the fat in one place it looks yellow.  If you look where butter comes from, butter comes from milk and it's yellow.  That's where the yellow colour comes from.  It's all conglomerated in one place and you can actually, physically see it.

March 2008


Balloons on a Tube

Find out why it is so hard to start blowing up a balloon and what it has to do with bubble bath.

What you need

Two Balloons

2 similar sized large balloons

Marker Pen Liid

A short piece of tube, slightly larger than the necks of the balloons. Some marker pen lids work nicely, or a piece of hose

 

 

What to Do

Stretch the neck of a balloon over one end of the tube.

Blow up the balloon through the tube so it just starts to stretch.

Twist its neck to keep the air in

Stretch the other balloon's neck over your tube.

Untwist the neck and see what happens.

Can you get the two balloons to stay at the same size?


What may Happen

The big balloon won't inflate the small one, and it should be very difficult to get both balloons to be the same size.


Naked Scientists Science Radio Show Home Who are The Naked Scientists Information about Naked Scientists
Naked Scientists Podcast Ask the Naked Scientists Podcast Question of the Week Podcast
Naked Science Articles Experiments to do at Home Science Discussion Forum
Science News Stories Answers to Science Questions Interviews with Famous Scientists

Information presented on this website is the opinion of the individual contributors and does not reflect the general views of the administrators, editors, moderators, sponsors, Cambridge University or the public at large.

Click here for the Naked Scientists PODCAST

The contents of this site are © The Naked Scientists® 2000-2012. The Naked Scientists® and Naked Science® are registered trademarks.