Science Questions

Can a planet orbit a black hole?

Tue, 4th Oct 2016

Listen Now    Download as mp3 from the show Why do Cats Have Vertical Pupils?


luke asked:

Just found your pod cast the other week. awesome podcast!


I was wondering if anyone has found a black hole that has captured another interstellar object. I am assuming that the creation of a black hole is so violent that anything that was originally in that solar system was blown away or consumed by the star prior to the formation of the black hole.


We put this question to Judith Croston... Black Hole

Judith - Yes. There are two bits to the question and so, if we think about how black holes can actually form, that sort of answers the second question about whether it would destroy the solar system.

So the best way we know about making a black hole is in whatís known as a supernova explosion, which is when a really big star basically collapses and then has a really big explosion. For two reasons, if you had a solar system at that point, so if there were planets around that star, they would get blown away, they would get destroyed and thatís partly because a lot of matterÖ there's actually less gravity and that means the planets can just go wandering off into space. But there are also shockwaves and all sorts of horrible things happening. So itís very unlikely that there would be a way for planets to survive when a black hole forms.

So if we found a planet, for example around a black hole, that would probably mean it had somehow had to get there afterwards. Either by forming around the black hole or by being captured, which is what the questioner is asking. So we havenít actually found any black holes that have planets orbiting around them, sadly.

Interestingly, there are some neutron stars that have planets around them which is kind of cool. But there are black holes that we think have captured other stars. So there are places where there are lot of stars very close together in the galaxy and we think that the chances of them banging into each other are such that itís quite likely, maybe, thereís a star orbiting around a black hole thatís actually been captured because theyíre really close together. And, actually those are some of the best ways we have of detecting the black holes in the first place is when the black holes pull stuff off the star and it falls in onto the black hole.

Caroline - So how could a star be near a black hole and not get sucked in by its immense gravity? How can a star orbit a black hole? It must surely arrive at huge speed or what happens?

Judith - Yes. So whether or not a star will get captured or fall into the black hole, as you say, it will depend on where itís coming from and how fast itís going. Now to actually get sucked into the black hole, it has to get incredibly close because, I think as I said a bit earlier, if you're far away from a black hole it just behaves like a star - the gravity just obeys the normal laws. If you want to actually get sucked into the black hole, you have to get pretty close and black holes are quite smalls, so the chances of that happening are, actually, pretty rare. Itís much more likely that it will get captured in an orbit and go around it. And, in fact, we can see some stars orbiting the black hole in the centre of our galaxy and we can just watch them travelling around in these quite fast orbits and see that they are actually orbiting around the black hole, which is kind of cool.


Subscribe Free

Related Content


Make a comment

Black holes are very hard to observe directly, because they are very black, and very small.

The massive black hole in the center of our galaxy is estimated to have a mass 4 million times that of the Sun, but would fit within Earth's orbit around the Sun. At a distance of 27,000 light-years, it is too small to see with optical telescopes, and it is surrounded by opaque dust clouds. However, networks of radio telescopes can peer through the dust, and detect radio waves produced by hot gas surrounding the (likely) black hole.

There are occasional X-Ray bursts from this object, which may be caused by a large object falling into the black hole.

Many galaxies (including our own) have high-velocity beams of particles emitted above and below the galaxy, which show up in radio wavelengths. It is thought that matter is actively falling into the black hole at the center of these galaxies, and perhaps 10% of it escapes along the poles of the black hole. In some cases, these jets suddenly change direction, suggesting that perhaps two black holes collided, changing the axis of rotation of the central black hole.

The recently observed gravitational waves were caused by the collision of two black holes, around 30 times the mass of the Sun.
evan_au, Thu, 11th Aug 2016

See the whole discussion | Make a comment

Not working please enable javascript
Powered by UKfast
Genetics Society