Evan Stanbury asked:
I have heard it said that bird lungs are more efficient than mammal lungs - the reason given was something to do with one-way flow and their hollow bones.
I haven't been able to find anything understandable about it on the internet - is this true?
Where would the air go after it went into their bones?
Chris - I only discovered how different the respiratory system of birds is when I started to actually teach this to the Natural Sciences students at the University of Cambridge a few years ago and itís ingenious what goes on. Birds need a very efficient respiratory system, because they have such high metabolic rates, in order to sustain the enormous work output that they do when they fly.
So how do their chests work? Well they have a very different system to the lungs that we do. We have lungs which are like two pairs of balloons that you blow air into, they inflate and then they recoil down, blowing the air out again. Birds have a one-way flow of air through their lungs. They don't have tiny air sacs called alveoli like we do. They have tiny tubes called air capillaries that the air flows through continuously and the benefit of doing that is that you always have fresh air flowing through the lung, maintaining a very high concentration of oxygen up against the bloodstream and therefore, you maximise the gradient for diffusion, pushing oxygen into the blood.
How do they do this? Well if you were to dissect a bird, what you would see is they have these combinations of lung tissue for want of a better word and air sacs. Now the air sacs are in various parts of the body. They are called anterior and posterior air sacs as two groups. When the bird breathes in, it moves various bones and muscles in order to increase volume of these air sacs anteriorly and posteriorly, so they draw air into them. But, first of all, the air flows into the trachea and it goes into the posterior air sac. The anterior air sacs which also increase in volume, they actually get filled up by the air that's already in the birdís lung. So in other words, they pull air through the lung tissue into their anterior air sac. Then when the bird breathes out, exhales, it squeezes on these air sacs. This time, the posterior air sac empties into the lung tissue and the anterior air sac empties into the birdís trachea and then out through its nostrils and its beak. So in this way, you've always got air going in one direction through the lung. Itís always fresh air and therefore, you've always got a very high oxygen gradient taking air into the tissue.
These air sacs are also making use of spaces inside some of the birdís bones including its humorousí shoulder bones and also its vertebrae. And so, that means that the bones are very, very light which the bird needs as an adaptation for flight.
Evan Stanbury asked the Naked Scientists: Hi... I have heard it said that bird lungs are more efficient than mammal lungs - the reason given was something to do with one-way flow and their hollow bones. I haven't been able to find anything understandable about it on the internet - is this true? Where would the air go after it went into their bones? Thanks Evan What do you think? Evan Stanbury , Tue, 7th Jun 2011
You have not directly answered the question, but I infer the answer is: yes, bird lungs/respiratory system is more efficient. And in a geologic era where free atmospheric oxygen is scarcer, I would expect mammals to compete more poorly than now. Hemo_jr, Mon, 10th Feb 2014