Naked Science Forum

Non Life Sciences => Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology => Topic started by: Dick1038 on 28/11/2007 01:53:33

Title: Before the Big Bang
Post by: Dick1038 on 28/11/2007 01:53:33

According to what I have read, there was nothing before the BB: no space, no time, no nuthin'. Theorists have used QT to explain the birth of the universe (a quantum fluctuation).  If there were really nothing at all, then there shouldn't be QT either.

Big Bang theorists have yet to explain the origin and composition of all that dark matter.

I feel that once everything about the universe has been settled, the universe will throw another curve ball at us.

Title: Before the Big Bang
Post by: lyner on 28/11/2007 12:53:59

That's how it always is. The Victorians had almost come to the conclusion that Physics was all done and dusted - then, along came Modern Physics.
Another Russian doll lies inside the one we can see at the moment.

Title: Before the Big Bang
Post by: neilep on 28/11/2007 22:57:25

Quote from: syhprum on 28/11/2007 21:13:56

This problem was discussed on 21/11/07

http://www.thenakedscientists.com/forum/index.php?topic=11534.0

Title: Before the Big Bang
Post by: lightarrow on 30/11/2007 19:29:34

Quote from: Dick1038 on 28/11/2007 01:53:33

Big Bang theorists have yet to explain the origin and composition of all that dark matter.

With dark energy is even worse, and this time for QFT too.

Title: Before the Big Bang
Post by: socratus on 01/12/2007 19:03:04

Quote from: Dick1038 on 28/11/2007 01:53:33

According to what I have read, there was nothing before the BB: no space, no time, no nuthin'. Theorists have used QT to explain the birth of the universe (a quantum fluctuation).  If there were really nothing at all, then there shouldn't be QT either.

Big Bang theorists have yet to explain the origin and composition of all that dark matter.

I feel that once everything about the universe has been settled, the universe will throw another curve ball at us.

=========================
there was nothing before the BB: no space, no time, no nuthin'...........
It was only Either/ Vacuum which is possible to underatand
with formula : T=0K.
But no body interesting in this simple fact.

Title: Before the Big Bang
Post by: Dick1038 on 04/01/2008 22:06:07

My humble opinions: If there was no space, there was no vacuum. If there was no vacuum, there was no Quantum Field. If there was no time, then nothing can happen.