The Naked Scientists

The Naked Scientists Forum

Author Topic: Is there proof that inflation had a beginning?  (Read 692 times)

Offline Bill S

  • Neilep Level Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 1797
  • Thanked: 11 times
    • View Profile
Is there proof that inflation had a beginning?
« on: 06/11/2015 21:22:23 »

Guth, Vilenkin and Borde propose the following thought experiment:  Imagine a universe filled with particles. As it steadily expands, the distance between particles grows. It follows that observers sprinkled throughout this expanding universe would be moving away from each other until, eventually, they occupied widely scattered regions of space. If you happened to be one of those observers, the farther an object was from you, the faster it would be moving away.

Now throw into the mix a space traveler moving through space at a fixed speed: He zooms past Earth at 100,000 kilometers per second. But when he reaches the next galaxy, which is moving away from us at, say, 20,000 kilometers per second, he will appear to be moving only 80,000 kilometers per second to observers there. As he continues on his outward journey, the space traveler’s speed will appear smaller and smaller to the observers he passes. Now we’ll run the movie backward. This time, the space traveler’s velocity will appear faster and faster at each successive galaxy.

If we assume inflation is eternal into the past — that it had no beginning — the space traveler will eventually reach and overtake the speed of light. A calculation by Borde, Guth and Vilenkin showed that this would happen in a finite amount of time. But according to the laws of relativity, it is impossible for any massive object to reach the speed of light, let alone exceed it. “This cannot happen,” says Vilenkin. “So when you follow this space traveler’s history back in time, you find that his history must come to an end.”

“The fact that the traveler’s journey backward in time hits an impasse means that there’s a problem, from a logical standpoint, with the assumption of an ever-expanding universe upon which this whole scenario is based. The universe, in other words, could not always have been expanding. Its expansion must have had a beginning, and inflation — a particularly explosive form of cosmic expansion — must have had a beginning, too. By this logic, our universe also had a beginning since it was spawned by an inflationary process that is eternal into the future but not the past.”

This works only if time reversal is invoked, and the galaxies are moving closer together, with their closing speed, relative to the galaxy at which the astronaut turned, decreasing.  This would give the required effect, but is it fairytale physics?


The Naked Scientists Forum

Is there proof that inflation had a beginning?
« on: 06/11/2015 21:22:23 »


SMF 2.0.10 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines
SMFAds for Free Forums