The Naked Scientists

The Naked Scientists Forum

Author Topic: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion  (Read 1741 times)

Offline marzosia2

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 93
    • View Profile



Q1= question 1
Please reply me for my 18 qestions
Q1.... (yes/no )   .....short description why ? 
Q2.... (yes/no )   .....short description why ?
Q3.... (yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q4....(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q5...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q6...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q7...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q8...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q9...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q10...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q11...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q12...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q13...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q14...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q15...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q16...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q17...(yes/no ) .....short description why ?
Q18...(yes/no ).....short description why ?

after above list please prepare few words:
opinion about  My instrument and test
opinion about my proposition how to reduce Cost for LIGO
opinion about  "conclusion after experiment " (possibble not ?  respect to what DOPPLER ?) You have Your own Idea arguments  / counterexamples / other exmples from Your own work life 



I'm ready here for Your Questions :
( 2012-2016 - during my work I made many  tests

 very nice tool is Digital camera
-HUGE SENSOR 16Mpx - feel/see near  200 000 points (single picture )
 ( exist in web many free programs to evaluate picture's histograms / colour)

 Very important is DARK filtre ( more long picture's time = more better average )
- I CAN GIVE YOU MORE INFO ( I not represent any company - my dark filtre I made alone I just want to help You prepare test /experiment )


I DREAM REPEAT MY TEST IN INTERNATIONAL TEAM
WHAT I CAN DO ? (I'm private person I not working for any Universitet)
CAN YOU HELP ME  - any informations (thank You) 





IT IS POSSIBLE or NOT possible TO MEASURE RED SHIFT ?



Q1: Astronomer on moon SEE DOPPLER or NOT  ?
Q2: Astronomer on big planet  SEE DOPPLER or NOT  ?
Q3: Astronomer on moon = Astronomer on BIG PLANET ( the same speed and distance L ) ?



Q4: Astronomer on Big Planet see Doppler or NOT
(em source central position )  ?

EM source's position is not central
 (exist distance center----X1) 


Q5: Astronomer on moon see Doppler or NOT ?
Q6: Astronomer on Big Planet see Doppler or NOT ?

Below Autocad 2014
( without math this program not works
this what is showing drawing we can describe by functions )



Q7: Source 3Hz what is Your opinion
 Sensor ( astronomer ) see the same Hz ?
Q8: Astronomer see /not see Doppler  ?

We have two situations
(left em source is central )
(right - em source is not central X1)



Q9: We have many obser. o1..o2....o(n-1)...  THEY ALL SEE THE SAME Hz ?

Q10:We have many obser. o1..o2....o(n-1)... THEY ALL SEE DIFFERENT RED SHIFT Hz  ( different = not the same Hz but red )?

Q11:We have many obser. o1..o2....o(n-1)... THEY ALL SEE ZERO  SHIFT Hz ?
( They all see the same Hz )


EXPERIMENTAL PART ( I MADE TEST IN 2012)

inside 100% Dark box we have BULB and " classical FILM "




bulb = source
film = sensor
« Last Edit: 15/03/2016 06:21:07 by marzosia2 »


 

Offline marzosia2

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 93
    • View Profile
Re: Simple test Many Questions
« Reply #1 on: 14/03/2016 15:35:13 »
Q12: What is registering FILM Zero , BLUE, RED shift ?
Q13. HOW  SHIFT is registering FILM  ?
 
distance  Bulb ----Film  =  L  (meters )

L1=1 m
L2=2 m
L3=3 m

Q14: HOW DEEP  RED WE WILL SEE (we changing distance L)  ?

A ) L1<L2<L3

L3 strong shift , L2 medium SHIFT , L1 soft shift

B) L1=L2=L3 = ZERO SHIFT ( Michelson Morley  ? I saw this zero many time in TV  )

C) L1>L2>L3 

L1 strong SHIFT , L2 medium SHIFT , L3 soft shift

Q15: Reapect to what Film is registering ZERO SHIFT ?
Q16: Respect to what Film is not registering ZERO SHIFT ?

INTRESTING TEMPERATURE PROBLEM

( during my work I  found TEMPERATURE PROBLEM
In my opinion more better is describe this experiment  by  INVERSE SQUARE LAW
I not have money to buy much more better laser so I started look 3D model  that is how I found DOPPLER ... )

Please Compare Marosz's test to FIRST Michelson Morley
first M-M look very similar ( They also are using cheap light's source)


EM wave = Radio wave = Light

3D signal is more nice to describe 3D space

Q17: Do we have ZERO ? or we HAVE DOPPLER ?
Q18: Marosz's test You want to repeat in home ? 

I ALREADY INFORMED LIGO TEAM ABOUT MY TEST
I TRUST THAT MATHEMATICA and DOPPLER CAN REDUCE COST
and PROBLEMS !





theory - below informations please find in books
( I'm sorry they are very popular so I not add source )

1600 Galilean relativity /Natural Fall Law

1861 J. C. Maxwell, published his theory of electromagnetic fields and radiation,
 which shows that light has momentum and thus can exert pressure on objects.
1901  P. N. Lebedev EXPERIMENTAL EXAMINATION OF LIGHT PRESSURE

2011 Grover Swartzlander first began to examine a revolutionary concept
in optical physics after studying the flight of a moth.
He watched the animal use its wings to create lift, which led to flight. 
Swartzlander asked : Could light be used to create the same effect?


EM Pascal Si UNITS system



« Last Edit: 15/03/2016 05:36:38 by marzosia2 »
 

Offline Colin2B

  • Global Moderator
  • Neilep Level Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1921
  • Thanked: 125 times
    • View Profile
Re: Simple test Many Questions
« Reply #2 on: 14/03/2016 17:22:01 »
Please change your subject to a question and ask a science question in your post, otherwise your post could be moved or deleted.
Thank you.
 
The following users thanked this post: marzosia2

Offline chris

  • Neilep Level Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 5339
  • Thanked: 65 times
  • The Naked Scientist
    • View Profile
    • The Naked Scientists
Re: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion
« Reply #3 on: 14/03/2016 19:23:32 »
Seconded; posting reams of spurious poorly phrased rubbish with no clear point or direction is spam and will be deleted in 24 hours if this is not remedied.
 

Offline marzosia2

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 93
    • View Profile
Re: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion
« Reply #4 on: 15/03/2016 05:12:46 »
Seconded; posting reams of spurious poorly phrased rubbish with no clear point or direction is spam and will be deleted in 24 hours if this is not remedied.

I'm sorry I reedit post  PLEASE reply  for  my 18 questions
« Last Edit: 15/03/2016 05:15:09 by marzosia2 »
 

Offline Thebox

  • Neilep Level Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 3164
  • Thanked: 46 times
    • View Profile
Re: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion
« Reply #5 on: 15/03/2016 09:36:08 »


I'm sorry I reedit post  PLEASE reply  for  my 18 questions

I actually understand this poster's post.   He is asking you if there is really a doppler  redshift or is the long arm really just becoming zero and the inverse square law collapses.

Quote
Q1: Astronomer on moon SEE DOPPLER or NOT  ?

No, it is too close.


Quote
Q2: Astronomer on big planet  SEE DOPPLER or NOT  ?

No, it is to close

Quote
Q3: Astronomer on moon = Astronomer on BIG PLANET ( the same speed and distance L ) ?

Yes the length is the same, the speed of light in either direction should take the exact same amount of time to travel the length.



Quote
Q4: Astronomer on Big Planet see Doppler or NOT
(em source central position )  ?

No, to close



Laser= 3 dimensional light


spacial light = singularity


contraction =   >r=<A   where A is area and r is radius









« Last Edit: 15/03/2016 10:00:28 by Thebox »
 

Offline marzosia2

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 93
    • View Profile
Re: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion
« Reply #6 on: 15/03/2016 13:13:24 »

THANK YOU FOR REPLY !
I HOPE WE WILL FIND PROBLEM ( MY POST TARGET IS LEARN ME MORE ...  )


PLEASE REPLY AGAIN  ON MY QUESTIONS AFTER STUDY BELOW

SORRY THAT I USING  TEST FORM  ( Q1..Q2...)
( my english is not good  Yes/Not is very good form )

Later I want to build LOGIC EQUTION
for example

fact A  Q1= YES ( TURUE )
fact B  Q2= NO ( FALSE )


Fact A + Fact B  = ......

if A = TRUE  ==> B = ....

FINALY in THAT POST I WANT TO BUILD EVIDENCE ( mathematica TRUE/FALSE )
it will be very important fact for mathematica ( and physics too )



OK LET'S START
I MARKED YOUR FIRST REPLY by BLUE COLOUR


Q1 "No, it is too close."

aditional informations  please reply again for Q1 after read

Fact A Huge distance we have Doppler
Fact B Small distance we have Doppler

Doppler can be STRONG or SOFT  ( Red colour can be bright OR dark )

Q2 - please use above explanation



Q3 " Yes the length is the same, the speed of light in either direction should take the exact same amount of time to travel the length. "

OK perfect !


Q4 No, to close

please  reply again


THANK YOU







 

Offline Thebox

  • Neilep Level Member
  • ******
  • Posts: 3164
  • Thanked: 46 times
    • View Profile
Re: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion
« Reply #7 on: 15/03/2016 14:05:31 »




OK LET'S START
I MARKED YOUR FIRST REPLY by BLUE COLOUR


Q1 "No, it is too close."

aditional informations  please reply again for Q1 after read

Fact A Huge distance we have Doppler
Fact B Small distance we have Doppler

Doppler can be STRONG or SOFT  ( Red colour can be bright OR dark )


THANK YOU

Fact A Huge distance we have Doppler = expand Y linear contracting area X,Y of object

Fact B Small distance we have Doppler =Expand area X,Y of object expanding Y



As the object gets nearer to you the light is stretched of the object.  As the objects moves away from you the light is stretched between you and object.

In imagination imagine you are standing on a train track, looking ahead the track narrows to a point of 0 dimension, looking behind you the track narrows to 0 dimension.

Now imagine you are at a crossroads, all the roads narrow to  0 dimensions.



















« Last Edit: 15/03/2016 14:16:48 by Thebox »
 

Offline marzosia2

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 93
    • View Profile
Re: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion
« Reply #8 on: 15/03/2016 17:00:02 »


TABLE's  ANGLE
RESPECT TO PLACE WHERE SIGNAL STARTED ?






please back to Questions form
« Last Edit: 16/03/2016 03:40:02 by marzosia2 »
 

The Naked Scientists Forum

Re: 18 questions ( Yes/ not ) Please give Your opinion
« Reply #8 on: 15/03/2016 17:00:02 »

 

SMF 2.0.10 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines
SMFAds for Free Forums