0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: chiralSPO on 06/10/2015 14:11:13and cannot get any closer to the nucleusWhat force will prevent that?Also, there is only one logic of continuity of motion regardless of size scale...
and cannot get any closer to the nucleus
Well, please give an example where a particle would vanish from current position and appear in different location or change velocity and or position (jump) instantaneously...
Quote from: mathew_orman on 06/10/2015 14:24:46Quote from: chiralSPO on 06/10/2015 14:11:13and cannot get any closer to the nucleusWhat force will prevent that?Also, there is only one logic of continuity of motion regardless of size scale...No force required to prevent it. The nucleus and electrons in an atom all have the same center of mass—it is impossible for them to be any closer.
Quote from: mathew_orman on 06/10/2015 14:39:29Well, please give an example where a particle would vanish from current position and appear in different location or change velocity and or position (jump) instantaneously...The emission and absorption of x-rays are everyday examples of single-quantum phenomena Some of my colleagues use protons and neutrons to treat tumors.
True, but some of that radiation is deflected by an electric field, and some isn't. Some is deflected by a magnetic field, and some isn't. Some of it travels at the speed of light and some doesn't. Some is strongly absorbed by lead and some by water (it's a quantum thing, but I'm sure there's a logical explanation too).
And what is the setup that proves all that?
Rephrased question:And what is the setup that demonstrate all that?
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/particles/neutrondis.html
Chadwick was a student of Rutherford and would not dare to provide an objective interpretation of the experiments results...
Should I believe in logical reasoning or in what Wiki claims?
I am only interested in progress based on discovery of properties of matter...Unfortunately all evidence shows that assumed properties ware invented and then experiments tailored to support invented properties ware deliberately misinterpreted...Resulting in useless knowledge which fails every time one puts together even the simplest atomic simulator, simulating molecule of Hydrogen...Means that we need to get back to lab and start from the scratch if we want to make a real progress...
Unfortunately all evidence shows that assumed properties ware invented and then experiments tailored to support invented properties ware deliberately misinterpreted...