0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
No, I'm simply taking his word for it.
Yes, it's dead. The post of 17/04/2021 20:11:27 super-seeds the post of 17/04/2021 20:04:00.
I can keep the mass circle spinning smoothly and let the charge circle rotate at half the angular speed. In order for the electron to look the same after two mass circle rotations.
still dragging the corpse around?
That still breaks the conservation laws for the same reasons as before.
I don't see it breaking any conservation laws.
Quote from: talanum1 on 16/04/2021 19:09:10Is it possible that the electron magnetic moment oscillates at a very rapid rate?No.Because, if it did, I could put one near a coil of wire and get it to generate free energy.
Is it possible that the electron magnetic moment oscillates at a very rapid rate?
So, come up with a better model.
The textbooks cannot give a reason why the electron don't look the same after one rotation.
The electric charge circle rotates at 1/4 x the speed of the mass charge circle
Looked at from the side, a rotation looks like an oscillation and an oscillating
Quote from: Bored chemist on 19/04/2021 20:31:51Looked at from the side, a rotation looks like an oscillation and an oscillatingRotating charge is necessary for it to have a magnetic moment.
Looking at it isn't going to make it decide it's oscillating.
There is no requirement for the charge to rotate physically.
.No, but looking at it might convince YOU that it is oscillating and thus will emit EM radiation.
Quote from: Colin2B on 20/04/2021 09:36:12There is no requirement for the charge to rotate physically.That's just what they tell you on order that they can claim the particle is a point. You must then come up with another explanation for the magnetic moment. My model explains it explicitly.Quote from: Bored chemist on 20/04/2021 09:43:42.No, but looking at it might convince YOU that it is oscillating and thus will emit EM radiation.It doesn't matter if I see it oscillating, it matters how it really is.
The textbooks cannot give a reason why the electron don't look the same after one rotation.It's not really a rotation, so why would they look the same?
Quote from: Bored chemist on 19/04/2021 20:31:51The textbooks cannot give a reason why the electron don't look the same after one rotation.It's not really a rotation, so why would they look the same?One would think Bored chemist can read. If it's not really a rotation wouldn't it always look the same?
One would think Bored chemist can read.
It's not really a rotation, so why would they look the same?
If I had said"A duck is not really a cabbage, so why would they look the same?",would you have understood that?