Naked Science Forum

On the Lighter Side => That CAN'T be true! => Topic started by: Jhon on 25/05/2008 22:29:07

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to escape?
Post by: Jhon on 25/05/2008 22:29:07

Jhon asked the Naked Scientists:

If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to escape?
What do you think?

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to escape?
Post by: Karen W. on 26/05/2008 00:08:55

I believe the body will suffocate eh? .. As far as exploding I would think as the body dies there will be gas expelled in the bowels and assuming the body was left I would assume decomposition begin at that point and would produce enough gas inside that perhaps it would explode after a amount of time.. but as for the soul.. the soul knows no bounds at least that is my opinion.. nothing can hold the soul in least it be bound by unsettled unfinished work.. but that is more a spiritual thing then anything..

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to escape?
Post by: Bored chemist on 26/05/2008 01:03:07

Ignoring the fact that there's no evidence that the soul exists, from time to time people get trapped in places and die.
It used to be the case that old fridges killed children who, while playing, closed themselves inside, shut the door, and suffocated.
If the non existent soul could break out there wouldn't have been any need to legislate for fridges that could be opened from the inside.

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: einsteinium252 on 29/07/2008 20:58:34

I agree, the soul acts on a different plane of existance, with no material density.  Therefore, it would be quite easy for something with no material density to pass through a solid object.  Some people who believe in ghosts and things from 'the other side' say that ghosts just pass through walls.
However, it's hard enough to prove the existance of such things as it is.

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: Set on 31/07/2008 06:28:37

Well I would hope you had learned about Dark matter and that its properties allow it to move through 3d objects.  And that it is possible to study it in extremely cold conditions where the molecules slow down to an observable rate.

Well whats to say souls aren't capable to moving in a manner such as this on a higher dimensional plane of energy?

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: Bored chemist on 31/07/2008 06:55:32

How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: that mad man on 31/07/2008 16:10:48

As stated, you first need to define what a soul is.

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: Bored chemist on 31/07/2008 18:55:56

And then you probably need to discuss it on a forum dedicated to something other than science.

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: JnA on 01/08/2008 05:39:42

Quote from: Jhon on 25/05/2008 22:29:07

Jhon asked the Naked Scientists:

If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to escape?
What do you think?

Literature clearly states that the person will stay in a near death state for one hundred years until true loves first kiss drops by.

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: bryan on 04/08/2008 15:18:32

Most glass in soul-permeable. But I have recently invented soul-impermeable glass, when you die your soul is retained inside the glass. If you are worried about where you are going when you die for £50,000 I can build you a soul-box. Instead of burning in hell your soul can spend eternity in this box equipped with TV, your favourite artworks etc. Your loved ones can even come visit.

£50,000 is a small price to pay to avoid eternity in Hell.

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: Bored chemist on 04/08/2008 19:36:45

Bryan, That looks an interesting offer. Have you had any complaints from dissatisfied previous customers?

Title: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul trying to
Post by: bryan on 05/08/2008 12:15:52

100% satisfaction gauranteed. Not a soul complaint yet.

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: duffyd on 03/04/2020 20:28:38

Don't know, but I break everything else.
God is spirit and they who worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth, so I would say my spirit/soul will immediately exist in the presence of God without moving an inch.

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: duffyd on 04/04/2020 01:03:34

Quote from: Bored chemist on 31/07/2008 06:55:32

How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

47 to 106

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: syhprum on 04/04/2020 13:32:15

Could you create a special section for posts where the word god is used ?

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: duffyd on 05/04/2020 00:54:48

Quote from: duffyd on 04/04/2020 01:03:34

Quote from: Bored chemist on 31/07/2008 06:55:32

How many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

47 to 106

Roughly. 13 to 76 by some accounts.

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: syhprum on 05/04/2020 09:30:17

The proper translation of angels is messengers if messenger particles can have their dimensions defined it is possible to answer the question

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: syhprum on 05/04/2020 09:34:05

"Literature clearly states that the person will stay in a near death state for one hundred years until true loves first kiss drops by"
I think that is was more than a mere kiss in the original story Sleeping beauty regained consciousness giving birth 

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: Monox D. I-Fly on 08/04/2020 08:04:45

Quote from: syhprum on 05/04/2020 09:34:05

"Literature clearly states that the person will stay in a near death state for one hundred years until true loves first kiss drops by"
I think that is was more than a mere kiss in the original story Sleeping beauty regained consciousness giving birth 

Poor baby surviving 9 months in the womb without nutrition.

Title: Re: If you put a near-death person in a sealed glass box, will the glass box explode, the soul tryin
Post by: alancalverd on 08/04/2020 23:50:10

The quantum theory of ghosts explains it all. Ghosts are mostly found in castles with thick walls from which they can't escape, but they can flow through doors and internal partitions, and wander down corridors unimpeded, and they tend to move away from light, which gives us some idea of the inertial mass of a ghost. It's a simple tunnelling phenomenon. So to answer the original question, no, the pressure of a soul on a solid is very small but if the glass is thin enough the soul will tunnel through it rather than break it.