0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Do you agree there is physical things in a R³ space?
Quote from: Thebox on 27/02/2018 21:45:50likewise electrostatic pointsAgain- gibberish.What do you actually mean by this?
likewise electrostatic points
Quote from: Thebox on 27/02/2018 21:37:14If something has dimensions, it can be point like but cannot be a point. An electron is a point like particle that the physics suggests , with a hollow core. What experiment showed the electron to have a hollow core?
If something has dimensions, it can be point like but cannot be a point. An electron is a point like particle that the physics suggests , with a hollow core.
None of the counterpoint you have raised has been valid.Your suggestion is full of holes.You should abandon it.
The physics shows it
Quote from: Thebox on 27/02/2018 22:05:11The physics shows itWhat physics shows it?
Coulombs law . Newtons third law.
Quote from: Thebox on 27/02/2018 22:11:26Coulombs law . Newtons third law. How do these prove anything about whether subatomic particles have volume or not?
« on: Today at 05:12:44 pm » Quote (selected)Quote from: Thebox on Today at 05:11:26 pmCoulombs law . Newtons third law. How do these prove anything about whether subatomic particles have volume or not?
It shows that a likewise polarity, point like particle , all points would be repulsive points, the only outcome can be a hollow centre, giving the point like particle dimensions.
Quote from: Thebox on 27/02/2018 22:17:08It shows that a likewise polarity, point like particle , all points would be repulsive points, the only outcome can be a hollow centre, giving the point like particle dimensions. What experiment has demonstrated that electrons are composed of multiple points?
I cannot think of any experiment that does show electrons are composed of multipoints, however that being said...Is it possible for electrons to by composed of multiple points?
If so, how would that be either tested, or expounded upon?
It does not need an experiment , a point is 0 dimension, so for something to exist and have dimension, it has to be surrounding points of a point. 0 point + 0 point = r=1x4/3π(1x)³ = 3d
What experiment demonstrated that electrons have dimension?
The maths demonstrated that an electron has to have dimension to exist.
Quote from: Thebox on 27/02/2018 22:41:45The maths demonstrated that an electron has to have dimension to exist.Please provide an outside link to the math you speak of. In other words, I'm not asking for math you made up, but math that is well-supported by the existing physics community.
If the electron has a volume
Quote from: Thebox on 27/02/2018 22:51:23If the electron has a volumeWe've already been through this: what experiment has demonstrated that electrons are spheres or have volume? I'm concerned that you might be working yourself into a circular argument.
Colliding two electrons will always produce two scattered electrons, and it may sometimes produce some photons from initial and final state radiation
I will give you an experiment, emit some electrons directed at some electrons. QuoteColliding two electrons will always produce two scattered electrons, and it may sometimes produce some photons from initial and final state radiation If they had no volume there would be nothing to collide.