0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
In a sentence - what doesn't work at the moment which will do once we accept that uncertainty is the fifth dimension? Please give a substantive answer and not just another vague quotation.
It could provide a useful step in the shift from modernity to post-modernity.
In a sentence - what doesn't work at the moment which will do once we accept that uncertainty is the fifth dimension?
I do have an answer that does it in four measures: three components of momentum, and one of energy. Then you have a plane wave describing the particle's state exactly*, which also includes its uncertainty relations. What do you find wrong with this description?*: When I say exactly, what I mean is that the state is determined to the fullest extent that quantum mechanics allows. This automatically includes the uncertainty relations, since they're built into the rules of quantum mechanics. That's exactly what Hawking's quote is saying--that quantum mechanics builds uncertainty into the laws of physics--not that uncertainty requires an additional measurement to be made.
JP I have only just seen this reply. Not sure why it did not come up before.So you are saying that there are four dimensions plus a plane wave. And the plane wave, which includes uncertainty relations, is not a fifth measure? With due respect that does not sound very convincing. It has all the hallmarks of trying to provide adequate desciptors without challenging the 4D paradigm. Just sweep uncertainty under the scientific carpet.Little wonder some people are averse to having philosophers take a close look at scientific thought. Thank for the question and the explanation.Regards, Clem.
It is fairly clear that we come from rather different orientations. You are obviously determined to hold on to your point of view, which is your prerogative.
http://xkcd.com/675/
Thanks Geezer,Regards, Sandstone.