1
General Science / Is the Curie Effect Reversible
« on: 30/07/2024 14:50:14 »
So this website says that the Curie Effect is not reversible: heating above the Curie point results in a permanent loss of magnetism.
This seems to contradict the operation of the Weller soldering irons that I spent my whole working life using: they have bits with a magnetic pellet that it releases a spring-loaded armature to open the switch contacts when the bit reaches it's set temperature and attracts it again as it cools.
Reading Wikipedia, they make no mention of whether it's reversible or not, and Chat GPT starts by saying that it is, then agrees with the site that says it isn't, then when I point out it's contradicting itself says that there are two Curie Effects: one reversible and the other not.
I see that the original site makes note of a separate effect that's not the Curie Effect, but which causes a reversible loss of magnetism which is progressive not sudden, but I'm sceptical that's what Weller are using, as without a sudden loss at a particular temperature, the switching point would be dependent on the armature spring as well as the bit, and much more difficult to calibrate. Weller call their system Magnastat without reference to Curie, and although they don't explain in any detail how it works, they do refer to a change in characteristics at a specific temperature.
This seems to contradict the operation of the Weller soldering irons that I spent my whole working life using: they have bits with a magnetic pellet that it releases a spring-loaded armature to open the switch contacts when the bit reaches it's set temperature and attracts it again as it cools.
Reading Wikipedia, they make no mention of whether it's reversible or not, and Chat GPT starts by saying that it is, then agrees with the site that says it isn't, then when I point out it's contradicting itself says that there are two Curie Effects: one reversible and the other not.
I see that the original site makes note of a separate effect that's not the Curie Effect, but which causes a reversible loss of magnetism which is progressive not sudden, but I'm sceptical that's what Weller are using, as without a sudden loss at a particular temperature, the switching point would be dependent on the armature spring as well as the bit, and much more difficult to calibrate. Weller call their system Magnastat without reference to Curie, and although they don't explain in any detail how it works, they do refer to a change in characteristics at a specific temperature.