Naked Science Forum

General Science => General Science => Topic started by: mrsmith2211 on 02/01/2016 09:37:38

Title: Why do magnets attract each other in one orientation, but not another?
Post by: mrsmith2211 on 02/01/2016 09:37:38
Title: Re: Why do magnets attract each other in one orientation, but not another?
Post by: chris on 02/01/2016 10:40:19
The intensity of a magnetic field falls according to an inverse square law: in other words, the force of attraction is proportional to 1/d^2 (one over distance squared); that is, if you double the distance between them, the force will be 1/(2 squared), or one quarter of what it was at the previous separation.

I speculate that the magnets are mounted on a non-susceptible, non-magnetic back-plate, which are effectively acting as spacers, dramatically reducing the field intensity.

[EDIT ADDED: See the link from Evan two posts below, which explains this perfectly.]
Title: Re: Why do magnets attract each other in one orientation, but not another?
Post by: evan_au on 02/01/2016 20:54:27
Oops! The video didn't appear until after I wrote a response... Thinking about it, it's possible that the magnets form a Hallbach array (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halbach_array), but I'm not clear how this would perform a useful function in a hard disk drive (apart from an emergency data eraser).

It's not clear what type of magnet you are considering, but...

*At this point you may wonder why the North pole of your bar magnet is attracted to the North pole of the Earth. This is because the North pole of the Earth is actually the "South" pole of a big bar magnet inside the Earth(!)
Title: Re: Why do magnets attract each other in one orientation, but not another?
Post by: evan_au on 02/01/2016 21:20:19
This web page explains that these are the head actuator magnets for a hard disk drive.
http://www.reuk.co.uk/Hard-Disk-Drive-Magnets-For-Wind-Turbines.htm

In the disk drive, these magnets form a cavity which has a north pole at one end, and a south at the other. A computer-controlled electromagnet moves backwards and forwards within the cavity to move the read/write head across the surface of the disk.

It is very important that magnetic fields do not spread beyond the actuator, or it could demagnetize the hard disk, losing the stored data near the rim of the disk. To prevent this, the magnets would be encased in a soft-iron backing plate, which acts as a magnetic shield; this "shorts out" the external magnetic field on the backing plate side, while focusing an intense magnetic field on the interior of the cavity. 
Title: Re: Why do magnets attract each other in one orientation, but not another?
Post by: alysdexia on 17/01/2016 14:09:24
inverse cube

The soft iron conducts half of a magnètic circuit with both poles.  I don't think it focuses like a Halbach array or other homopolar arrangement: https://www.quora.com/How-much-power-and-wire-do-I-need-to-create-a-5-tesla-electromagnet/answer/Autymn-Castleton.