Naked Science Forum

General Discussion & Feedback => Just Chat! => Topic started by: Just thinking on 13/07/2021 20:10:28

Title: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 13/07/2021 20:10:28
Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy? We are very fortunate to live on this earth as we are governed by a multitude of coincidences. I will list some and maybe you can add some more we live under a single sun, the sun is the correct temperature, we are at the correct distance from the sun, we have the moon, we have the ocean tides, the earth has its tilt, we have our seasons, we have water, we have oxygen, we have precipitation, we have vegetation, we have craters, The list can go on and on I think if any of these things were removed or in some cases just altered we would cease to exist. we live in a house of cards please don't pull a card out. 
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Petrochemicals on 13/07/2021 21:17:25
Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy? We are very fortunate to live on this earth as we are governed by a multitude of coincidences. I will list some and maybe you can add some more we live under a single sun, the sun is the correct temperature, we are at the correct distance from the sun, we have the moon, we have the ocean tides, the earth has its tilt, we have our seasons, we have water, we have oxygen, we have precipitation, we have vegetation, we have craters, The list can go on and on I think if any of these things were removed or in some cases just altered we would cease to exist. we live in a house of cards please don't pull a card out. 
Yes but we do not use copper in our blood, are not made from silicon and do not breathe nitrogen.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 14/07/2021 04:39:45
Yes but we do not use copper in our blood, are not made from silicon and do not breathe nitrogen.
Yes but we do not use copper in our blood, are not made from silicon and do not breathe nitrogen.
We will have to be careful if we move then.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: alancalverd on 14/07/2021 20:10:33
Could we exist elsewhere in the galaxy? Probably, if you use a fairly broad definition of "we". It wouldn't surprise me if organic life once evolved on Mars.

Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy? No.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 14/07/2021 20:48:04
It wouldn't surprise me if organic life once evolved on Mars.

Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy? No.
I appreciate your opinion but I don't believe we could be anywhere else as life is very special only to this planet that of course is a matter of opinion.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Eternal Student on 14/07/2021 22:48:21
Hi.

Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?  How much technology are we allowed to bring with us?
    Some human beings do exist (for quite a long time) on the International Space Station.   Very long term exposure to these conditions will start to have detrimental effects but it's not difficult to imagine that as our technology improves we can build better space stations where human beings can remain for arbitrarily long periods of time.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 15/07/2021 12:16:08
Hi.

Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?  How much technology are we allowed to bring with us?
    Some human beings do exist (for quite a long time) on the International Space Station.   Very long term exposure to these conditions will start to have detrimental effects but it's not difficult to imagine that as our technology improves we can build better space stations where human beings can remain for arbitrarily long periods of time.
Thanks for your reply my post title is a bit incomplete sorry I was thinking more about what the likelihood was for a planet elsewhere in the galaxy that might have all that is necessary for life similar to the one we have. What you stated is very interesting and I won't put my hand up to travel for any distance or time in a tin can anyway I would not want to be anywhere near the launch pad.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: alancalverd on 15/07/2021 21:02:05
life is very special only to this planet
Hence the importance of defining "we". It seems that bacteria and lichens could thrive on Mars without terraforming. Once you have established something capable  of manufacturing carbohydrates and proteins from sunlight, CO2 and H2O, you could introduce all sorts of anaerobic predators.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 15/07/2021 21:12:45
you could introduce all sorts of anaerobic predators.
It is possible that some type of fish or other aquatic species is below the ice on mars and if so then that would open the door for life throw out the universe but until they find life on another planet my bet is we are all alone.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 17:27:53
Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy? We are very fortunate to live on this earth as we are governed by a multitude of coincidences. I will list some and maybe you can add some more we live under a single sun, the sun is the correct temperature, we are at the correct distance from the sun, we have the moon, we have the ocean tides, the earth has its tilt, we have our seasons, we have water, we have oxygen, we have precipitation, we have vegetation, we have craters, The list can go on and on I think if any of these things were removed or in some cases just altered we would cease to exist. we live in a house of cards please don't pull a card out.

Am I wrong or did you just ask if we could exist in the black hole at the center of our galaxy?

I think that the answer is clear to most people
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 18:21:02
Am I wrong or did you just ask if we could exist in the black hole at the center of our galaxy?

I think that the answer is clear to most people
Look like you have court me out silly me I thought I would have fooled everyone.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 18:25:14
Am I wrong or did you just ask if we could exist in the black hole at the center of our galaxy?

I think that the answer is clear to most people
Look like you have court me out silly me I thought I would have fooled everyone.

Why are you trying to fool people in the first place?
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 18:29:22
Why are you trying to fool people in the first place?
I just like to look smart because I'm not.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 19:11:02
Why are you trying to fool people in the first place?
I just like to look smart because I'm not.
If you want to look smart, be honest truthful and help your neighbor.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 19:35:57
If you want to look smart, be honest truthful and help your neighbor.
I see and so does my friend your little title Europa has just been busted your a fool. Your no wedge you are the split in cheap firewood. So much for intelligence you fool this site can connect you with your other stupid name. BUSTED.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 19:43:52
Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy? We are very fortunate to live on this earth as we are governed by a multitude of coincidences. I will list some and maybe you can add some more we live under a single sun, the sun is the correct temperature, we are at the correct distance from the sun, we have the moon, we have the ocean tides, the earth has its tilt, we have our seasons, we have water, we have oxygen, we have precipitation, we have vegetation, we have craters, The list can go on and on I think if any of these things were removed or in some cases just altered we would cease to exist. we live in a house of cards please don't pull a card out. 
Yes but we do not use copper in our blood, are not made from silicon and do not breathe nitrogen.

Actually the human body needs copper, nitrogen and silicon.  Silicon is in the skin, copper is essential for nerves and nitrogen carries Oxygen in red blood cells.  And by the way you are breathing Nitrogen now
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Bored chemist on 19/07/2021 20:06:33
Why are you trying to fool people in the first place?
I just like to look smart because I'm not.
If you want to look smart, be honest truthful and help your neighbor.
So... don't post conspiracy tosh on a science web-page then...
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 20:25:46
So... don't post conspiracy tosh on a science web-page then...
who got lost you me or the other person I'm lost. Wat just happen. Did I miss something?
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Bored chemist on 19/07/2021 20:31:42
So... don't post conspiracy tosh on a science web-page then...
How got lost you me or the other person I'm lost. Wat just happen. Did I miss something?
Europa is not practicing what he preaches.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 20:34:40
So... don't post conspiracy tosh on a science web-page then...
How got lost you me or the other person I'm lost. Wat just happen. Did I miss something?
Europa is not practicing what he preaches.
Yea I do not practice anything off of the Earth.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 20:36:26
Europa is not practicing what he preaches.
Thank god for that.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 20:42:25
Yea I do not practice anything off of the Earth.
Please Europa just join in and have a say all is good hear and you are welcome just get ready for correction as we all do.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 21:32:44
Yea I do not practice anything off of the Earth.
Please Europa just join in and have a say all is good hear and you are welcome just get ready for correction as we all do.

Well if you want a simpler answer, no we as humans could not exist anywhere in the galaxy.  See the surface of our sun is in the galaxy as is the surface of Jupiter and Neptune, just to name a few places that we could not live
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 21:44:10
Well if you want a simpler answer, no we as humans could not exist anywhere in the galaxy.  See the surface of our sun is in the galaxy as is the surface of Jupiter and Neptune, just to name a few places that we could not live
Ok you have had your fun and I get it anyone that concerns themself with this topic in this way is obviously not real in the other topic so my pity is in vain and your effort is also in vain so touchy my friend. And to think I fell for it.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 21:51:50
Well if you want a simpler answer, no we as humans could not exist anywhere in the galaxy.  See the surface of our sun is in the galaxy as is the surface of Jupiter and Neptune, just to name a few places that we could not live
Ok you have had your fun and I get it anyone that concerns themself with this topic in this way is obviously not real in the other topic so my pity is in vain and your effort is also in vain so touchy my friend. And to think I fell for it.
Actually you ask a question and I answered it.  No we can not live anywhere in the galaxy
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 22:03:51
Actually you ask a question and I answered it.  No we can not live anywhere in the galaxy
No you just stated a few places the sun some of the planets hardly the universe. I tell you what stop responding and wasting my time hang on I just got a call from Alfa conga I will catch you later all the best from planet earth.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 19/07/2021 22:20:05
Actually you ask a question and I answered it.  No we can not live anywhere in the galaxy
No you just stated a few places the sun some of the planets hardly the universe. I tell you what stop responding and wasting my time hang on I just got a call from Alfa conga I will catch you later all the best from planet earth.
LOL you did not ask about the universe your question was.  Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?

So again the answer is no we can not live anywhere in the galaxy, or in the universe if you want to stretch it that far.  If you think that we can live in space or on suns or on frozen ice comets you simple do not comprehend that we can not live anywhere. 

Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 22:28:01
that we can not live anywhere. 
zzzzzzzz Im losing you zzzzzz can you hear me zzzzzz I will reestablish  contact with you in zzzzzzzzz future zzzzzzz let me no wen you are betterzzzzzzzz god luck with your recovery zzzzzzzzzz
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 19/07/2021 22:55:00
Has it gone away I'm ducking and weaving?
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 20/07/2021 01:16:05
Has it gone away I'm ducking and weaving?
Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 20/07/2021 01:45:49
Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?
zzzzzzzz halzzzzzzzzcazzzzzzzzsoorzzzzzzzzzimlosingzzyouzzzzzzz
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 20/07/2021 01:48:54
Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?
Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?
zzzzzzzz halzzzzzzzzcazzzzzzzzsoorzzzzzzzzzimlosingzzyouzzzzzzz

Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 20/07/2021 01:56:08
Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?
No, it was a question for all to answer and my answer is it is most likely NO. It was not a trick question.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 20/07/2021 16:27:37
It would be interesting if we did make it to another planet that is orbiting a star in our galaxy and as we look out the window coming into land we see dinosurs should we land no thanks we would be like pet food in a tin.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 20/07/2021 19:45:03
It would be interesting if we did make it to another planet that is orbiting a star in our galaxy and as we look out the window coming into land we see dinosurs should we land no thanks we would be like pet food in a tin.
LOL what if Charlton Heston was there running away from apes on horseback screaming it's a madhouse? 

PS. What exactly is a dinosurs?
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 20/07/2021 20:12:40
PS. What exactly is a dinosurs?
That's just how they speel dinosaurs on that planet. And I thought Chalten Heston returned back to earth that's not thousands of light years away. ps. My speel check is playing up.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Bored chemist on 20/07/2021 20:15:47
Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?

Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Yes- briefly


Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 20/07/2021 20:21:14
Why don't you answer your own question.  Can you exist anywhere in the galaxy?  Why would such an obtusely infantile question even be posed as the obvious answer is NO.  So do you disagree?

Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Yes- briefly

Nope as life can be brief however existence implies extended life.

continued survival.
"she helped to keep the company alive when its very existence was threatened"

https://www.google.com/search?q=existence+definition&rlz=1C1UEAD_enUS946US946&oq=existence+&aqs=chrome.5.69i57j0i433l2j46i433j0i433l2j0l2j46j0.4683j0j15&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Bored chemist on 20/07/2021 20:27:26
existence implies extended life.
No.

What you tried to do there was pretend that one of the definitions extends to all uses of the word.
And you aren't clever enough to get away with that sort of slight of hand, are you?
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 20/07/2021 20:31:36
existence implies extended life.
No.

What you tried to do there was pretend that one of the definitions extends to all uses of the word.
And you aren't clever enough to get away with that sort of slight of hand, are you?

Wrong again Son because you could never exist even momentarily on the surface of the Sun because you would be dead long before you got there.

Yawning

Like I said given enough time I will be wrong, but you will never see this
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Bored chemist on 20/07/2021 20:39:34
Wrong again Son
LOL
because you would be dead long before you got there.
Nobody asked if you could travel there, they asked if you could exists there.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 20/07/2021 20:41:45
Wrong again Son
LOL
because you would be dead long before you got there.
Nobody asked if you could travel there, they asked if you could exists there.
Again you could not exist on the surface of the Sun, no matter how short the time interval.

There is a logic section to standard IQ test for a reason.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Bored chemist on 20/07/2021 21:02:26
Again you could not exist on the surface of the Sun, no matter how short the time interval.
And yet, you could.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_units#Planck_time_and_length

I'm familiar with IQ tests- from some time ago.
I presume you have done lots of them.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Just thinking on 20/07/2021 21:05:33
Again you could not exist on the surface of the Sun,
What if you go in the winter.
Title: Re: Could we exist anywhere in the galaxy?
Post by: Europa on 21/07/2021 14:05:38
Again you could not exist on the surface of the Sun,
What if you go in the winter.
Or at night?