0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Mark Beardmore asked the Naked Scientists: My question is about gravity. Einstein taught us that gravity is a warping of spacetime which causes objects to describe a curved path in the presence of matter. On the other hand, quantum mechanics tells us that gravity is communicated by tiny particles (gravitons) zipping backwards and forwards between two objects.How can both be true? Please enlighten me.Thank you for the wonderful podcasts you produce.Mark BeardmoreBristol, UK.What do you think?

Quote from: thedoc on 06/04/2014 23:30:01Mark Beardmore asked the Naked Scientists: My question is about gravity. Einstein taught us that gravity is a warping of spacetime which causes objects to describe a curved path in the presence of matter. On the other hand, quantum mechanics tells us that gravity is communicated by tiny particles (gravitons) zipping backwards and forwards between two objects.How can both be true? Please enlighten me.Thank you for the wonderful podcasts you produce.Mark BeardmoreBristol, UK.What do you think?They are both supposed to be right and looked at from different points of view. Einstein's general theory of relativity is a classical theory which describes the gravitational field whereas quantum theory describes the mechanism of gravity. re - Einstein taught us that gravity is a warping of spacetime which causes objects to describe a curved path in the presence of matter. - That is a myth. Einstein never taught us that. That's a common misconception about Einstein. While it's true that spacetime is curved in regions of spacetime where there are tidal gradients, gravitational fields can also be present in flat spacetime. It's wrong to think of curved spacetime as a actually being synonymous with gravity.So there's no problem with them both being right. Einstein describes gravity with his field equations while quantum gravity describes the mechanism of the gravitational interaction.

Thanks for the info on the two copy gluon thing. I actually passed over an article on that, and have called it back up to read, so again, thanks.And to PMB, I don't really picture "curved" spacetime. I imagine spacetime as the field of gravitational gradients, but who know, maybe the gluon similarity will go somewhere.Thanks!