The Naked Scientists
  • Login
  • Register
  • Podcasts
      • The Naked Scientists
      • eLife
      • Naked Genetics
      • Naked Astronomy
      • In short
      • Naked Neuroscience
      • Ask! The Naked Scientists
      • Question of the Week
      • Archive
      • Video
      • SUBSCRIBE to our Podcasts
  • Articles
      • Science News
      • Features
      • Interviews
      • Answers to Science Questions
  • Get Naked
      • Donate
      • Do an Experiment
      • Science Forum
      • Ask a Question
  • About
      • Meet the team
      • Our Sponsors
      • Site Map
      • Contact us

User menu

  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • Help
  • Search
  • Tags
  • Member Map
  • Recent Topics
  • Login
  • Register
  1. Naked Science Forum
  2. Non Life Sciences
  3. Chemistry
  4. What is a mineral?
« previous next »
  • Print
Pages: [1]   Go Down

What is a mineral?

  • 10 Replies
  • 2462 Views
  • 3 Tags

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline katieHaylor (OP)

  • Naked Scientist Producer
  • Global Moderator
  • Sr. Member
  • ********
  • 469
  • Activity:
    13.5%
  • Thanked: 1 times
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
    • The Naked Scientists
What is a mineral?
« on: 14/09/2017 11:29:38 »
Geoff asks:

What is a mineral? Some say it needs to be solid at room temperature and some say not.

Can you help?
Logged
 



Offline chiralSPO

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ********
  • 3453
  • Activity:
    6%
  • Thanked: 434 times
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #1 on: 14/09/2017 14:53:00 »
I think all common definitions of mineral require it to be solid in its natural state. But I don't agree that something has to be solid at room temperature to be considered a mineral (though that is typically a safe assumption).

My counterexample is... water ice!

In parts of our world where it is consistently below the freezing point of water, and especially on other worlds (like Europa, Enceledus and Pluto) water ice is always solid, and a very integral part of the "geology."

My understanding of the definition of mineral is:
A naturally occurring, solid substance with a well-defined composition. Some people include that it must be inorganic (meaning it contains no C-H bonds), but I'm not sure I agree with that, as it would rule out coal, amber, jet, and methane-water-clathrate (all of which are minerals in MY book). That said, I feel like a mineral should be formed through abiotic processes (even if the precursors of the mineral are biotic in origin)

To back myself up, I present:
http://www.minerals.net/mineral/ice.aspx
http://geology.com/articles/water-mineral/
« Last Edit: 15/09/2017 19:52:00 by chiralSPO »
Logged
 

Online evan_au

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum GOD!
  • ********
  • 9167
  • Activity:
    79.5%
  • Thanked: 908 times
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #2 on: 15/09/2017 05:37:38 »
Gold, Platinum and Silver are minerals, often found as native metal due to their non-reactive nature. These metals are concentrated in veins of intruded rock and differentiated by their various melting points.

Other metals are more reactive, and usually found as oxides, sulfides, etc (apart from the occasional nickel-iron meteorite that hasn't rusted away, yet).

My temporary counterexample is: Mercury.
- Mercury is often found in the form of Cinnabar (HgS), a solid red mineral.
- There are tales of lightning strikes in Cinnabar-rich rocks which caused liquid mercury to ooze out of the rocks.
- Due to its volatility, Mercury would eventually evaporate, and due to its reactivity it would react with oxygen or sulfur to form other solid mercury compounds.

But I suggest that in the temporary state of liquid mercury, it is still a mineral, which has been produced by natural processes in the lightning strike.
See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cinnabar
Logged
 

Offline glot

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • 30
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #3 on: 15/09/2017 13:27:25 »
I find it interesting that most things in science seem to require accuracy. Yet, when it comes to basic definitions, they are merely guidelines and left to one's personal interpretation.
Why should a mineral need to be solid in it's natural state? If we include solidified H2O, then why not also include solidified Co2 or solidified methane etc. They exist as a solid in their natural state on some planets. Are minerals only minerals once they are on Earth?
Logged
 

Offline chiralSPO

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ********
  • 3453
  • Activity:
    6%
  • Thanked: 434 times
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #4 on: 15/09/2017 15:12:34 »
Quote from: glot on 15/09/2017 13:27:25
I find it interesting that most things in science seem to require accuracy. Yet, when it comes to basic definitions, they are merely guidelines and left to one's personal interpretation.
Why should a mineral need to be solid in it's natural state? If we include solidified H2O, then why not also include solidified Co2 or solidified methane etc. They exist as a solid in their natural state on some planets. Are minerals only minerals once they are on Earth?

Categorizations are an aspect of human psychology. It is easier for us to think about the world by classifying objects, phenomena etc. And while it is useful, it is often flawed or superficial. Upon further inspection there are so many exceptions to the "rules."

We also get to choose which classification system we need to address different questions. My favorite example is the term "metal," which chemists use to classify over half of the periodic table (s block minus hydrogen, d block, f block, and the bottom half triangle of the p block), materials scientists use "metal" to mean any bulk material that has mobile charge carriers in the conduction band (this definition extends to a diverse array of materials, including some ceramics and even some proteins!), cosmologists use "metal" to describe any element other than hydrogen or helium, and musicians use "metal" to describe a genre of rock music based on complex riffs, virtuosic solos and high precision awesomeness.

I would certainly think of solid CO2 as a mineral on Mars or elsewhere.
Logged
 



Offline jeffreyH

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ********
  • 6807
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 174 times
  • The graviton sucks
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #5 on: 15/09/2017 17:43:21 »
And then there is mineral water. Should that not be mineral mineral? What if you put ice in it? Mineral mineral mineral.
Logged
Even the most obstinately ignorant cannot avoid learning when in an environment that educates.
 

Offline jeffreyH

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ********
  • 6807
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 174 times
  • The graviton sucks
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #6 on: 15/09/2017 17:57:06 »
Musical interlude.
Logged
Even the most obstinately ignorant cannot avoid learning when in an environment that educates.
 

Online evan_au

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum GOD!
  • ********
  • 9167
  • Activity:
    79.5%
  • Thanked: 908 times
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #7 on: 15/09/2017 21:53:03 »
The musical interlude describes minerals as being "inorganic".
Limestone is mined commercially, for example to use in cement; Wikipedia has this to say:
Quote
Limestone is a sedimentary rock, composed mainly of skeletal fragments of marine organisms such as coral, forams and molluscs. Its major materials are the minerals calcite and aragonite, which are different crystal forms of calcium carbonate (CaCO3).

So it is derived from living things, and it is mainly composed of two forms of calcium carbonate which are both described as minerals.
So would you call limestone a mineral?
Logged
 

Offline glot

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • 30
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #8 on: 16/09/2017 00:36:05 »
So, science doesn't have rules, just guidelines? I guess this would allow for more flexible thinking which is necessary for progress.
Logged
 



Online evan_au

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum GOD!
  • ********
  • 9167
  • Activity:
    79.5%
  • Thanked: 908 times
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #9 on: 16/09/2017 08:56:10 »
Thinking about it more, granite is a rock, which consists of many minerals.

I guess limestone is also a rock (not a mineral), which consists of many minerals. As well as Calcium Carbonate, Limestone typically also contains sand and silt deposited on the seafloor, which represent other minerals.
Logged
 

Offline vent

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • 10
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 1 times
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
Re: What is a mineral?
« Reply #10 on: 16/10/2017 09:57:12 »
AFAIK minerals refer to natural occuring compounds of misc elements. Not sure what the difference to rocks is though
Logged
 



  • Print
Pages: [1]   Go Up
« previous next »
Tags: chemistry  / mineral  / elements 
 

Similar topics (5)

Heat resistant dark mineral wanted.

Started by TitanscapeBoard Chemistry

Replies: 21
Views: 13670
Last post 21/04/2004 03:33:18
by tweener
Are there high yield undersea mineral resources?

Started by TitanscapeBoard Geology, Palaeontology & Archaeology

Replies: 5
Views: 11814
Last post 06/07/2004 02:07:53
by Exodus
How is the identity of an unknown mineral determined?

Started by dongBoard Geology, Palaeontology & Archaeology

Replies: 13
Views: 21472
Last post 09/12/2008 02:14:05
by JimBob
Calling all geologists - Where can I get some of the mineral olivine

Started by John ChapmanBoard Geology, Palaeontology & Archaeology

Replies: 26
Views: 19530
Last post 09/03/2009 21:29:25
by John Chapman
Is Salt The Most Abundant Mineral In The World ?

Started by neilepBoard General Science

Replies: 23
Views: 14806
Last post 02/12/2009 15:37:12
by JimBob
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...
  • SMF 2.0.15 | SMF © 2017, Simple Machines
    Privacy Policy
    SMFAds for Free Forums
  • Naked Science Forum ©

Page created in 0.203 seconds with 61 queries.

  • Podcasts
  • Articles
  • Get Naked
  • About
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe to newsletter
  • We love feedback

Follow us

cambridge_logo_footer.png

©The Naked Scientists® 2000–2017 | The Naked Scientists® and Naked Science® are registered trademarks created by Dr Chris Smith. Information presented on this website is the opinion of the individual contributors and does not reflect the general views of the administrators, editors, moderators, sponsors, Cambridge University or the public at large.