The Naked Scientists
  • Login
  • Register
  • Podcasts
      • The Naked Scientists
      • eLife
      • Naked Genetics
      • Naked Astronomy
      • In short
      • Naked Neuroscience
      • Ask! The Naked Scientists
      • Question of the Week
      • Archive
      • Video
      • SUBSCRIBE to our Podcasts
  • Articles
      • Science News
      • Features
      • Interviews
      • Answers to Science Questions
  • Get Naked
      • Donate
      • Do an Experiment
      • Science Forum
      • Ask a Question
  • About
      • Meet the team
      • Our Sponsors
      • Site Map
      • Contact us

User menu

  • Login
  • Register
  • Home
  • Help
  • Search
  • Tags
  • Member Map
  • Recent Topics
  • Login
  • Register
  1. Naked Science Forum
  2. Non Life Sciences
  3. Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology
  4. Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« previous next »
  • Print
Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Down

Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?

  • 51 Replies
  • 3933 Views
  • 0 Tags

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline PmbPhy (OP)

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 3810
  • Activity:
    1.5%
  • Thanked: 122 times
    • View Profile
Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« on: 17/04/2018 08:13:42 »
This is a leading question of course since I know the answer. I'm merely curious as to who believes it.

I'm good on my word so when I said I'd post the original letter by Einstein o Lincoln Barnette I meant it so here it is. Please see attachment.

In essence Einstein stated in no uncertain terms that gravity should not be thought of as a curvature of spacetime. Spacetime curvature is just the relativistic term for tidal gradients. He also stated the relativity does not geometrize physics anymore that EM or the distance between two points.


* Einstein_SR_GR.pdf (666.56 kB - downloaded 404 times)
« Last Edit: 17/04/2018 08:19:54 by PmbPhy »
Logged
 
The following users thanked this post: jeffreyH



Offline geordief

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • 388
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 7 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #1 on: 17/04/2018 11:10:17 »
So the geometrization can be seen as a geometric model bearing an  exceedingly close approximation to a deeper physicality ?(this being so on statistical grounds as the basis for this physicality is so  "deeply rooted" in the tiny interactions at possibly graviton levels.)

It is the model that is geometric according to   this letter?

A bit similar to the arguments as to why all physics can be reduced to maths and numbers....

EDIT:the geometric model has shown no signs of  becoming less accurate at "higher definition" levels ,though has it? (ie measuring gravity/curvature  at extremely small levels of mass/energy )

It is anticipated to break down at some point but that point seems not to have been reached or even "approached".
« Last Edit: 17/04/2018 18:03:19 by geordief »
Logged
 

Offline opportunity

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 1555
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 48 times
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
    • Do not change the URL below
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #2 on: 17/04/2018 12:05:37 »
The idea of gravity being a curvature of spacetime....is.... a fluid idea of bodies in motion undergoing relativistic effects dependent on underlying conditions. The first condition with these bodies is that they are massive and that there is a natural curvature in play with their relation to one another (orbits). The second condition is the play of light in those spatial regions.

I'm terrible at explaining this stuff, so hopefully it didn't offend.

I'd like to add more beyond this basic stuff......(?)

This is the physics section, not a new ideas symposium, so I look at the question and hesitate with an answer, such a good question.
Logged
What is physics without new ideas shed by the positive light of interest of others with new possible solutions to age old problems?
 

Offline jeffreyH

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ********
  • 6669
  • Activity:
    17%
  • Thanked: 172 times
  • The graviton sucks
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #3 on: 17/04/2018 13:12:20 »
Quote from: PmbPhy on 17/04/2018 08:13:42
This is a leading question of course since I know the answer. I'm merely curious as to who believes it.

I'm good on my word so when I said I'd post the original letter by Einstein o Lincoln Barnette I meant it so here it is. Please see attachment.

In essence Einstein stated in no uncertain terms that gravity should not be thought of as a curvature of spacetime. Spacetime curvature is just the relativistic term for tidal gradients. He also stated the relativity does not geometrize physics anymore that EM or the distance between two points.


* Einstein_SR_GR.pdf (666.56 kB - downloaded 404 times)

Somebody had to say it. Well done.
Logged
Even the most obstinately ignorant cannot avoid learning when in an environment that educates.
 

Offline opportunity

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 1555
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 48 times
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
    • Do not change the URL below
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #4 on: 17/04/2018 15:55:49 »
And the answer goes to.....the dude playing the flute we are making poetry to.....?

< I should make that my call sign >
« Last Edit: 17/04/2018 16:05:33 by opportunity »
Logged
What is physics without new ideas shed by the positive light of interest of others with new possible solutions to age old problems?
 



Offline geordief

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • 388
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 7 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #5 on: 17/04/2018 16:12:05 »
Quote from: opportunity on 17/04/2018 15:55:49
And the answer goes to.....the dude playing the flute we are making poetry to.....?

< I should make that my call sign >
Pan's People?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pan%27s_People   
Logged
 

Offline opportunity

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 1555
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 48 times
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
    • Do not change the URL below
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #6 on: 17/04/2018 16:13:54 »
I know.

Pan's pandemia.

I would like physics to have a few metaphors, but "math" seems to take centre stage, especially when billions of dollars and the investments of many are at stake......as a way to be serious about living. I love that. Couldn't love it less.

"Clearly" this response is in response to a question, yet please do not let this response, all members, detract you from the OP's question. Apologies if I answered outside of the OP's intent.


Who claimed gravity is a curvature of spacetime?

Einstein.

He didn't say spacetime is a curvature of gravity. Or did he, and is there a difference between saying gravity is a curvature of spacetime or spacetime is a curvature of gravity?


« Last Edit: 17/04/2018 16:41:02 by opportunity »
Logged
What is physics without new ideas shed by the positive light of interest of others with new possible solutions to age old problems?
 

Offline PmbPhy (OP)

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 3810
  • Activity:
    1.5%
  • Thanked: 122 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #7 on: 17/04/2018 17:09:07 »
Quote from: opportunity
Who claimed gravity is a curvature of spacetime?

Einstein.
Nope. It was Max von Laue. Did you read the PDF file I posted in the OP?
Quote from: opportunity
He didn't say spacetime is a curvature of gravity. Or did he, and is there a difference between saying gravity is a curvature of spacetime or spacetime is a curvature of gravity?
You can have spacetime with no curvature so no. They're not the same.
Logged
 

Offline saspinski

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • 104
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 6 times
  • Engineer
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #8 on: 17/04/2018 19:02:37 »
If the Riemann tensor is zero in a region of spacetime, is it possible a gravity field there?
Or, is it possible a Riemann tensor different from zero in a region and no gravity field there?
If the answer is no for both questions, then spacetime curvature <=> gravity.
Logged
 



Offline PmbPhy (OP)

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 3810
  • Activity:
    1.5%
  • Thanked: 122 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #9 on: 17/04/2018 21:00:16 »
Quote from: saspinski
If the Riemann tensor is zero in a region of spacetime, is it possible a gravity field there?
Yes. Without question. Its the affine connection that determines the presence of a gravitational field, no tidal forces.

Quote from: saspinski
Or, is it possible a Riemann tensor different from zero in a region and no gravity field there?
Yes. In fact if you have a gradiometer in free fall while in orbit of Earth then in that frame the gravitational field is zero but there are still tidal forces present.

Quote from: saspinski
If the answer is no for both questions, then spacetime curvature <=> gravity.
Wrong. And if I might add - Wow! You said all of that without reading the letter Einstein wrote. That's a problem in this thread and there's no excuse for it. In that letter Einstein wrote
Quote from: Albert Einstein
... what characterizes the existence of a gravitational field from the empirical standpoint is the non-vanishing of the components of the affine connection], not the vanishing of the [components of the Riemann tensor]. If one does not think in such intuitive (anschaulich) ways, one cannot grasp why
something like curvature should have anything at all to do with gravitation. In any case, no rational person would have hit upon anything otherwise. The key to the understanding of the equality of gravitational mass and inertial mass would have been missing.
Case closed.

Please folks. Before making a claim on a paper/letter first read the paper/letter. Otherwise you come off quite poorly. Okay? :)

I should note something very important here. It's not me that who discovered this point. It was Dr. John Stachel, someone whom I became friends with over the last 18 years. He wrote a paper which touched on this subject and gave me a copy. He's a great guy who had a lot of interesting friends and acquaintances such as Karl Popper and Wolfgang Rindler (may he rest in peace).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stachel
« Last Edit: 17/04/2018 21:13:27 by PmbPhy »
Logged
 

Offline jeffreyH

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ********
  • 6669
  • Activity:
    17%
  • Thanked: 172 times
  • The graviton sucks
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #10 on: 17/04/2018 21:29:22 »
Just a note. To understand affine connections you need to study differential geometry. It is not an easy road. People say all sorts of things about relativity without actually putting in the effort to study the subject. That is a shame because it is so rewarding.
Logged
Even the most obstinately ignorant cannot avoid learning when in an environment that educates.
 

Offline opportunity

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 1555
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 48 times
  • Naked Science Forum Newbie
    • View Profile
    • Do not change the URL below
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #11 on: 17/04/2018 22:29:36 »
PmbPhy, I applaud your archival work.

However the extract/letter you are referring to is central to "general" relativiity.

"Special" relativity has a differennt can of worms as Einstein would know.

Its is far easier to relate "special" relativity with geometry than "general" relatviity.......and I think this is the uniquue case of the letter you have provided.

Once again though, bravo for diigging this letter up.



« Last Edit: 17/04/2018 22:52:51 by opportunity »
Logged
What is physics without new ideas shed by the positive light of interest of others with new possible solutions to age old problems?
 

Offline saspinski

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • 104
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 6 times
  • Engineer
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #12 on: 18/04/2018 00:47:19 »
Quote from: PmbPhy on 17/04/2018 21:00:16
 
Yes. Without question. Its the affine connection that determines the presence of a gravitational field, no tidal forces.

Do you have an example? I can imagine a gravitational field generated by an infinite plane. In that case the field is uniform and there are no tidal forces. But infinite planes were not detected by astronomers until now.

Quote from: PmbPhy on 17/04/2018 21:00:16
Yes. In fact if you have a gradiometer in free fall while in orbit of Earth then in that frame the gravitational field is zero but there are still tidal forces present.

If there are tidal forces, and the Riemann tensor is not zero, some Christoffel symbols must be non zero. What according to the Einstein text (..non-vanishing of the components of the affine connection...) => gravitational field.


Logged
 



Offline PmbPhy (OP)

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 3810
  • Activity:
    1.5%
  • Thanked: 122 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #13 on: 18/04/2018 01:41:34 »
Quote from: saspinski
Do you have an example? I can imagine a gravitational field generated by an infinite plane. In that case the field is uniform and there are no tidal forces. But infinite planes were not detected by astronomers until now.
If you looked in MTW you'd see their example. But, sure. See:
http://www.newenglandphysics.org/physics_world/gr/grav_cavity.htm

Quote from: saspinski
If there are tidal forces, and the Riemann tensor is not zero, some Christoffel symbols must be non zero.
Not true. In a locally inertial frame in a curved spacetime all of the affine connections vanish but the Riemann tensor doesn't. That's because the Riemann tensor is a function of both the Christoffel symbols as well as their derivatives. See "Coordinate expression" at
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_curvature_tensor

Quote from: saspinski
What according to the Einstein text (..non-vanishing of the components of the affine connection...) => gravitational field.
You're making it about Einstein when in fact many others agree with him and its in all of his books. Its simple. How do you tell if there's a gravitational field in your living room? Simple; hold an apple in your hand while its stretched out and then let it go. If it drops to the floor at a rate independent of its mass (drop others with different masses to check this out) then there's a gravitational field in that room. How do you tell if there are tidal forces? Use sensitive equipment and measure the small changes in the field with height. If they exist then there are tidal forces present.

You could read Einstein's gravitational field by Peter M. Brown which is online at:
https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0204044

Yes. I wrote it. It should answer your questions. If not then your comments would be invaluable to me. :)
Logged
 

Offline saspinski

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • 104
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 6 times
  • Engineer
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #14 on: 19/04/2018 02:23:52 »
Quote from: PmbPhy on 18/04/2018 01:41:34
Not true. In a locally inertial frame in a curved spacetime all of the affine connections vanish but the Riemann tensor doesn't. That's because the Riemann tensor is a function of both the Christoffel symbols as well as their derivatives.

The Christoffel symbols are functions of position and time. If in a point and its neighborhood  they vanish, their derivatives also vanish at this point => Riemann tensor = 0.

About the example, it is too complicated to calculate the metric tensor and see if the Riemann tensor is zero. By the way, it is nomally said that if there are no tidal forces, the Riemann tensor is zero, but I don't know a proof from the tensor definition. 


Logged
 

Offline Bill S

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 3420
  • Activity:
    11%
  • Thanked: 97 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #15 on: 19/04/2018 20:59:07 »
Could be worth a look by those who have time to read books.  "Lighthearted" doesn't always mean poor information.

Einstein Didn't Say That: Exposing the Common Sense in Relativity Theory.
 Don Griffin

"Einstein Didn't Say That" is a lighthearted but respectful exploration of the everyday logic behind special and general relativity. The first person to use the term 'curved space' was not Einstein, and not a physicist, but a reporter for the New York Times, who needed a catchy headline. What did Einstein really say, or not say, about curved space, time travel, wormholes, traveling twins, extra dimensions, multiple universes, dark matter and more? Have we been sold more sizzle than steak? With the help of dozens of quotes from well-known physicists, but mainly from Einstein himself, the author tries to separate Einstein's original ideas from some of the speculation that those ideas inspired in others. This is not a textbook or a history of physics, but rather the personal story of an ordinary guy's delight in discovering
Logged
There never was nothing.
 

Offline jeffreyH

  • Global Moderator
  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ********
  • 6669
  • Activity:
    17%
  • Thanked: 172 times
  • The graviton sucks
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #16 on: 19/04/2018 23:34:52 »
Scientific theories aren't written in stone. Einstein may have formulated relativity theory but others have studied and worked on it since. To understand all the implications is not easy. It requires a lot of work. I myself have merely started to scratch the surface. There is an awful lot that I don't know. I am most interested in the mathematics and theoretical aspects. I will not likely be in the position to experiment. But it's my idea of fun.
Logged
Even the most obstinately ignorant cannot avoid learning when in an environment that educates.
 



Offline PmbPhy (OP)

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 3810
  • Activity:
    1.5%
  • Thanked: 122 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #17 on: 20/04/2018 13:35:47 »
Quote from: saspinski
The Christoffel symbols are functions of position and time. If in a point and its neighborhood  they vanish, their derivatives also vanish at this point => Riemann tensor = 0.
That' incorrect. It's only when both al the first derivatives a ad the Christoffel symbols and tthey all vanish is the spacetime flat. That doesn't mean there's no gravitational filed. In fact Einstein said that a gravitational field can be "produced" by a change in the frame of reference. This is not about a time varying thing like you're implying.

Since this thread was diverted from is purpose I'm brining it back on track. Einstein wrote
Quote from: Albert Einstein
... what characterizes the existence of a gravitational field from the empirical standpoint is the non-vanishing of the components of the affine connection], not the vanishing of the [components of the Riemann tensor]. If one does not think in such intuitive (anschaulich) ways, one cannot grasp why
something like curvature should have anything at all to do with gravitation.In any case, no rational person would have hit upon anything otherwise. The key to the understanding of the equality of gravitational mass and inertial mass would have been missing.
Please focus on the subject at hand, i.e. What Einstein actually said, regardless of whether you think that he was right opr wrong. Okay?

Quote from: Albert Einstein
About the example, it is too complicated to calculate the metric tensor and see if the Riemann tensor is zero.
Quote
It's rehire easy. See: http://www.newenglandphysics.org/physics_world/gr/uniform_force.htm
« Last Edit: 20/04/2018 13:48:38 by PmbPhy »
Logged
 

Offline PmbPhy (OP)

  • Naked Science Forum King!
  • ******
  • 3810
  • Activity:
    1.5%
  • Thanked: 122 times
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #18 on: 20/04/2018 16:09:13 »
[quote author=Bill S
"Einstein Didn't Say That" is a lighthearted but respectful exploration of the everyday logic behind special and general relativity. The first person to use the term 'curved space' was not Einstein, and not a physicist, but a reporter for the New York Times, who needed a catchy headline.
[/quote]
Awesome. Can you tell me what news paper it was in and how I can get a copy of it:?

I really appreciate this bill. I love you! :)  That ..doesn't mean we'll be taking warm showers in the wee hours of he morning - Clint Eastwood in "Heartbreak Ridge". I love that saying! :)
Logged
 

Offline saspinski

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • 104
  • Activity:
    0%
  • Thanked: 6 times
  • Engineer
    • View Profile
Re: Who claimed that gravity is a curvature in spacetime?
« Reply #19 on: 20/04/2018 16:26:57 »
Suppose a function f(x,y,z,t). f is zero in a region around (x0,y0,z0,t0). All derivatives of f are also zero. So, it is not possible all Christoffel symbols be zero while some of its derivatives escape this fate.
That is the reason for the Riemann tensor be zero in this case.
Logged
 



  • Print
Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Up
« previous next »
Tags:
 

Similar topics (5)

Is there a "force of gravity"?

Started by GeezerBoard Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology

Replies: 47
Views: 21547
Last post 01/01/2019 23:14:35
by PmbPhy
How does the water in a water balloon behave in zero gravity?

Started by paul.frBoard Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology

Replies: 3
Views: 5246
Last post 07/12/2008 12:44:13
by lyner
Does anti-matter produce anti-gravity?

Started by kenhikageBoard Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology

Replies: 12
Views: 7521
Last post 31/07/2017 20:40:35
by Kryptid
Why is it called dark matter instead of dark gravity?

Started by IAMREALITYBoard Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology

Replies: 20
Views: 6081
Last post 02/01/2019 18:55:23
by Professor Mega-Mind
Will a photon clock run at a different rate from an atomic clock under gravity?

Started by amritBoard Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology

Replies: 147
Views: 61142
Last post 07/06/2010 06:43:34
by Geezer
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...
  • SMF 2.0.15 | SMF © 2017, Simple Machines
    Privacy Policy
    SMFAds for Free Forums
  • Naked Science Forum ©

Page created in 0.205 seconds with 84 queries.

  • Podcasts
  • Articles
  • Get Naked
  • About
  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe to newsletter
  • We love feedback

Follow us

cambridge_logo_footer.png

©The Naked Scientists® 2000–2017 | The Naked Scientists® and Naked Science® are registered trademarks created by Dr Chris Smith. Information presented on this website is the opinion of the individual contributors and does not reflect the general views of the administrators, editors, moderators, sponsors, Cambridge University or the public at large.