Impaling Potatoes

14 September 2008



A potatoA potatoA strawA plastic drinking straw (it doesn't have to be bendy)


Try pushing the straw into the potato slowly - does it work?

Now hold the straw gently and stab it into the potato as straight and fast as possible.


You should find that if you push the straw in slowly it will just bend, but if you stab it quickly it can penetrate up to 50mm into the potato, or even all the way through before the straw collapses.

Stabbing very slowlyStabbing fast


If you look at the end of the straw it is very narrow and actually quite sharp, so if the straw doesn't collapse it will make a good knife.

There are two reasons why the straw penetrates better when moving quickly than slowly -  the straw is effectively stronger and the potato is easier to cut.

The straw is being compressed between your hand and the potato.  When you squash a flexible tube it will fail by bending and then buckling.  The more it bends the weaker it becomes until eventually it buckles and fails.

A straight strawPushing unevenly on the strawThe straw starts to buckleBending
If the straw is perfectly straight it is very strongIf the forces on it are not quite even it can start to bendIf it bends too far it buckles and becomes much weakerAfter it buckles it can bend very easily.

If you move very quickly the straw doesn't have time to buckle, this means it maintains its strength throughout the collision and it can penetrate the potato without getting damaged.

In fact if you are very careful about how straight you stab the potato and stop the straw buckling you can sometimes get the straw a long way in even moving slowly

This failure by buckling is the reason that the parts of structures that are in compression, such as columns have to be much wider than the wire ropes that are used to support similar loads under tension. The columns have to be very stiff to resist the buckling.

What about the impact speed?

If you use an axe it will cut through wood a lot better if you swing it at a piece of wood than if you just push it slowly the straw is the same. This is for two reasons. If the straw is moving slowly the surface has time to distort and spread out the force where as if you move fast the force is concentrated at the sharp tip of the straw.

Stabbing slowlyMoving into the potato fast
If you move slowly then the potato has time to deform, the stress is distributed and you are trying to break more layers at onceThe potato doesn't have time to distort so the force is very concentrated and you are only trying to break one layer at a time,

Also if the straw is moving quickly and hits the potato that resists its progress, for the straw and your hand to stop immediately would require the potato to apply an immense force on the straw. For every force there is an equal and opposite force so the straw must be applying the same force to the potato, which the potato can't stand so it breaks.

The effect of air pressure

There is an argument that you can get the straw through better if you put your finger over the end of the straw. This will mean that the air inside the straw compresses as the straw moves into the potato. This should work a bit like blowing up a balloon and so make the straw more rigid as it is inserted. From experience with normal drinking straws, I don't think this helps very much as the increased resistance you get to inserting the straw from the increased air pressure seems to cause the straw to buckle more than the pressure can resist. Although if you are using a large "Fast Food" Style straw the straw would be more liable to buckling, but be stronger under pressure so the results may be different


Add a comment