Science Questions

What loses heat fastest, a white or black surface?

Sun, 4th Sep 2011

Listen Now    Download as mp3 from the show Why do some animals dump indiscriminately?


Michael Karpman asked:

A black object will absorb thermal radiation more readily than a white object. So does a black object emit thermal radiation more readily than a white object?


Dave -   To really understand what's going on here, you want to understand how light is emitted and absorbed.  Essentially, when light is emitted, a photon of light comes in and hits an electron, giving it some energy so it increases its energy. 

Now whether itís absorbed or not will depend on the structure of the electrons [in the atom].  If there's somewhere for the electron to go, if it can increase it's energy level - and itís happy up there - then it will absorb the light.  If not, then the light can't be absorbed and carries straight on. But if it is absorbed, the substance looks black. If it isn't, itís white [because the light is reflected back].

This means that if you heat something up, if there's [a higher energy level] somewhere for the electrons to go up to, and itís black, then there's also somewhere for the electron to drop down to again, meaning that the substance will also emit energy. 

So if something is good at absorbing light then itís also good at emitting it.  So a black thing should be much better emitting light than a white thing.

Chris -   So if you have solar panels on your roof, for example, that are heating water, you don't want the water going through them when itís colder outside than the water is because you're turning them into very effective giant radiators.

Dave -   That's right. And if you want to cool down a spaceship, the only way of doing it is by radiation of infrared light, so you paint the outside of your spaceship or the bits of the radiators in really dark black, which is so much better at emitting the light a much better radiator.

Chris -   Alright; slight twist to the story Ė if you're a cricketer and your at Lords, assuming it is sunny on the occasion you're over there - not that weíve been having much sun lately Ė they wear white, ostensibly to reflect the heat back off. So would they be better off wearing black then, assuming they're going to get hot anyway, so they can radiate the light and the heat better with the black surface?

Dave -   They're very, very unlikely to be hot enough to be radiating more heat than the sun is putting down on them because the sun has got a kilowatt per square metre and you're going to have to be very, very warm before you're emitting that much heat.  So, I think youíre still better off being in white.


Subscribe Free

Related Content


Make a comment

See the whole discussion | Make a comment

Not working please enable javascript
Powered by UKfast
Genetics Society