0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
How would 5he earth stop orbiting? Would it grind to a halt or suddenly start travelling toward the sun? Did the sun dissappear or was the earth ejected such as in an orphan planet?
Anyway, other articles consider the journey toward the sun to be over in about 65 days but that seems to be because they reckon the tidal forces from suns gravity would rip the planet apart before we even reach the outer edges of the sun.
So it's easier if you just consider a simple 2-body case.
The quick and dirty method of computing the fall time is to assume the Earth's orbit is an extremely eccentric ellipse with the Earth's present distance being at perihelion. This puts the Semi major axis at half the perihelion distance, and you can just calculate half the period of such an orbit. This works out to be about 64 days.
Quote from: Janus on 25/09/2021 21:34:42This works out to be about 64 days. Thanks Janus. Have you taken into account that the earth is starting from a stand still it will take some time to get going?
This works out to be about 64 days.
Tidal forces wouldn't effect the answer significantly.
Hi again.Quote from: Janus on 25/09/2021 21:34:42The quick and dirty method of computing the fall time is to assume the Earth's orbit is an extremely eccentric ellipse with the Earth's present distance being at perihelion. This puts the Semi major axis at half the perihelion distance, and you can just calculate half the period of such an orbit. This works out to be about 64 days. Please check your use of the term perihelion. I think you want the earth at aphelion to start with. I'm also not sure that "perihelion distance" is a well defined term. See if the diagram in post #10 is what you were saying.
Hi again.Quote from: Janus on 25/09/2021 22:08:21Tidal forces wouldn't effect the answer significantly. You may very well be right but earth isn't a rigid body. It's a dangerously loose collection of techtonic plates. The possibility of earth breaking apart was an idea presented here:https://www.wired.com/2014/12/empzeal-earthfall/ I certainly haven't done anything with the tidal forces, it was only mentoned because their answer was less than 91 days but they make it clear that earth never reaches the sun. Best Wishes.
This gives Time to impact ≈ 64.7 days. Which means that at least two contributors are agreeing on the impact time (Janus and Eternal Student), if that helps you (Just Thinking).
Instead there is something more like an elastic collision, the body receives an infinite impulse and reverses direction of travel instantly. Fairly weird in my opinion.
Intuitive actually.