The Naked Scientists
Toggle navigation
Login
Register
Podcasts
The Naked Scientists
eLife
Naked Genetics
Naked Astronomy
In short
Naked Neuroscience
Ask! The Naked Scientists
Question of the Week
Archive
Video
SUBSCRIBE to our Podcasts
Articles
Science News
Features
Interviews
Answers to Science Questions
Get Naked
Donate
Do an Experiment
Science Forum
Ask a Question
About
Meet the team
Our Sponsors
Site Map
Contact us
User menu
Login
Register
Search
Home
Help
Search
Tags
Recent Topics
Login
Register
Naked Science Forum
Non Life Sciences
Physics, Astronomy & Cosmology
What would be the impacts of disproving the Einstein's equivalence principle?
« previous
next »
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Down
What would be the impacts of disproving the Einstein's equivalence principle?
3 Replies
5156 Views
4 Tags
0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.
me-yass
(OP)
First timers
1
Activity:
0%
Naked Science Forum Newbie
What would be the impacts of disproving the Einstein's equivalence principle?
«
on:
31/05/2022 00:26:04 »
Hi all, i'm new here, and i just want to ask some experts what would be the impact if someone disprove Einstein equivalence principle and the strong equivalence principle. Does someone thinks it could be possible to violate them? Would that mean General Relativity is wrong?
Logged
paul cotter
Naked Science Forum King!
2320
Activity:
27.5%
Thanked: 260 times
forum grump
Re: What would be the impacts of disproving the Einstein's equivalence principle?
«
Reply #1 on:
31/05/2022 08:55:48 »
It would most likely indicate an error on your behalf. Caution: i am not an expert.
Logged
Did I really say that?
Eternal Student
Naked Science Forum King!
1832
Activity:
7.5%
Thanked: 470 times
Re: What would be the impacts of disproving the Einstein's equivalence principle?
«
Reply #2 on:
03/06/2022 01:56:23 »
Hi and welcome.
There was a discussion about almost exactly this a short while ago..... I'm having trouble finding it but I'll look for a bit longer.
LATE EDITING: No I can't find it, maybe it was a long time ago.
Best Wishes.
«
Last Edit: 03/06/2022 02:12:04 by
Eternal Student
»
Logged
Eternal Student
Naked Science Forum King!
1832
Activity:
7.5%
Thanked: 470 times
Re: What would be the impacts of disproving the Einstein's equivalence principle?
«
Reply #3 on:
03/06/2022 03:25:46 »
Hi again.
Well, you need more than just the Equivalence Principle (EP) to derive General Relativity. There are other theories of gravity that are consistent with the EP. The Brans-Dicke theory of gravity is one obvious example.
...the Brans–Dicke theory of gravitation (sometimes called the Jordan–Brans–Dicke theory) is a theoretical framework to explain gravitation. It is a competitor of Einstein's theory of general relativity...
...Both Brans–Dicke theory and general relativity are examples of a class of relativistic classical field theories of gravitation, called metric theories....
....
All metric theories satisfy the Einstein equivalence principle,
.....
[Taken from
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brans%E2%80%93Dicke_theory
]
So, there is something about General Relativity that makes it especially favoured. That is mainly that it has proven to be extremely useful and accurate. It has made predictions and they have held up well in reality. None of that will change if some experiment discovers a minor breech or failure of the EP.
We already know, or strongly believe that General Relativity (GR) has limits and is only an approximation. You are probably already aware that GR doesn't match up with Quantum theories well and you've probably also heard that it is unlikely there is a genuine singularity in a black hole. So, if something did happen, some experiment managed to falsify the EP, then yes... that does establish that GR can't be exactly right BUT so what? We knew that already. GR is just an approximation but a very good and useful one and it will almost certainly remain that way for many years.
Newtonian mechanics is only an approximation and a less accurate one than Relativity but it is still so useful that we continue to teach it in schools and universities.
Best Wishes.
Logged
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Up
« previous
next »
Tags:
equivalence principle
/
general relativity
/
gravity
/
einstein
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...