[Bored chemist]

I am building it so I can have corrective surgery. No working wheel, no life ever.

You need a plan B.

[Kryptid]

Of course if I get this working then it will be a black eye for the scientific community.

We have proof that it won't work.

Gravity has no energy, right? That's why it has to generate its own energy

Did you not read what I posted about potential energy?

[JLindgaard]

 I'm not going to post in here anymore so it doesn't matter. I mean the video in the OP shows that a mechanical advantage can be gained. That kind of proves it is possible. I also saw your kind remarks to someone who posted about potential energy. This means that I am being singled out because I am not welcome here because I do not like bored chemist. He hasn't shown where he knows anything yet has God status. I don't think a "real" science forum would make someone a God. I think that's all I really need to know.

[Bored chemist]

He hasn't shown where he knows anything

Yes I have; it's just that you didn't understand it.


post count.jpg (34.08 kB . 259x458 - viewed 1211 times)

I don't think a "real" science forum would make someone a God.

It's a joke.

. I think that's all I really need to know.

Nope, you also need to know about the conservation of energy.

This means that I am being singled out because I am not welcome here because I do not like bored chemist.

Nobody cares if you like me.
It's not as if you actually know me anyway.

But there's something important you need to realise.
You are not arguing with me, you are arguing with the laws of physics.

You might have a chance against me.

[Colin2B]

I'm not going to post in here anymore so it doesn't matter.

Good

[Kryptid]

I mean the video in the OP shows that a mechanical advantage can be gained. That kind of proves it is possible.

No, it doesn't. Noether's theorem proves it's impossible.

I also saw your kind remarks to someone who posted about potential energy. This means that I am being singled out because I am not welcome here because I do not like bored chemist.

I don't see how one thing is related to another. Neither yours nor perPedes' machines will work. You not liking Bored Chemist has nothing to do with it.

He hasn't shown where he knows anything yet has God status. I don't think a "real" science forum would make someone a God.

Bored Chemist does not have God status. The term "Naked Science Forum GOD!" is a title automatically applied to any member when they make enough posts. Someone who posts genius content and someone who posts stupid content will both receive that title if they make enough posts. It has no correlation to their authority or intelligence here.

[alancalverd]

"Mechanical advantage" is the ratio of output distance or angle to input movement. It does not (cannot) imply an increase in power or energy.

[perPedes (OP)]

its funny to read this, because while you see the maschine is runing, you tell us the whole day why its imposible that such a maschine will run   

[Origin]

you tell us the whole day why its imposible that such a maschine will run

Correct, a perpetual motion machine is not possible.  If your machine is running it is not a perpetual machine.

[perPedes (OP)]

and where does the energy come from, that spins the chain and compensates the friction ?

[Origin]

and where does the energy come from, that spins the chain and compensates the friction ?

Where indeed!  Perpetual motion requires magic energy to work.

[Bored chemist]

Correct, a perpetual motion machine is not possible.  If your machine is running it is not a perpetual machine.

And, just to clarify, if it's not running, it's not a perpetual motion machine.

[perPedes (OP)]

theres no magic, theres formulas, the problem is, you cant handle even such easy formulas

[Bored chemist]

theres no magic, theres formulas, the problem is, you cant handle even such easy formulas

There's  plenty of formulae.
If you misuse them you can convince yourself that PM is possible.
But you won't convince anyone who understands why it's impossible and, more importantly, you won't fool reality.

[perPedes (OP)]

only two sides with 5 formulae. no problem. and sources. not my formulae, that are yours, you claim at least

[Bored chemist]

no problem.

There's a very clear problem.
You think you have a perpetual motion machine, but you don't.

[alancalverd]

the problem is, you cant handle even such easy formulas

But you  can, so bring us the working machine.

[perPedes (OP)]

year of course, to bring it to you, would be much easier than you build the maschine in two days by your own, pumpkin

[Bored chemist]

much easier than you build the maschine

It's still impossible to build the machine.

[perPedes (OP)]

of course its imposible - for you for sure. a engineer needs ferrofluid, magnetical chain and a vessel. and viola