The Naked Scientists
Toggle navigation
Login
Register
Podcasts
The Naked Scientists
eLife
Naked Genetics
Naked Astronomy
In short
Naked Neuroscience
Ask! The Naked Scientists
Question of the Week
Archive
Video
SUBSCRIBE to our Podcasts
Articles
Science News
Features
Interviews
Answers to Science Questions
Get Naked
Donate
Do an Experiment
Science Forum
Ask a Question
About
Meet the team
Our Sponsors
Site Map
Contact us
User menu
Login
Register
Search
Home
Help
Search
Tags
Recent Topics
Login
Register
Naked Science Forum
General Science
General Science
Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
« previous
next »
Print
Pages: [
1
]
2
Go Down
Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
25 Replies
17429 Views
0 Tags
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Ultima
(OP)
Sr. Member
488
Activity:
0%
Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
on:
21/07/2004 21:54:33 »
Walking home from work today triggered a memory off... but it was of a dream I had had. The memory was as vivid as when I had first had the dream, the smell, muscle sensation, vision, thoughts, everything was there... it was kind of disconcerting and I had to force myself not to think about it.
When this happened was I merely remembering the dream or going off on a day dream?
I’m a bit scared by this since I’ve read that remembering dreams can lead to mental illness, and I remember most of my dreams, but never like this before and not all of a sudden. Someone tell me they’ve had the same experience and that everything’s ok [
]. please…
wOw the world spins?
«
Last Edit: 18/01/2018 09:01:30 by
chris
»
Logged
wOw the world spins?
neilep
Withdrawnmist
Global Moderator
Naked Science Forum GOD!
21211
Activity:
0%
Thanked: 119 times
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #1 on:
21/07/2004 22:59:33 »
....all I can say Matt to support you is that I remember my dreams too...and as long as I keep on taking the tablets the doctors think I'll be ok !!!!!!!!![
][
]...NO...SERIOUSLY MATT....I do remember my dreams and I find it very hard to believe that remembering them is indicative of a mental illness, sounds like total and complete bullsh_it to me!!...and I can remember dreams from many years ago..and YES I've had the same experience when something during the course of a day has triggered the memory of a dream with all the symptoms that you have had too....DO NOT WORRY....You are fine.......if there is any truth in the remembering dream = mental illness thing then I would have to think that you would have to be remembering dreams all day every day for a long long time etc etc.....and that the memories would have to be causing you serious distress......but don't get into a state cos you just read it somewhere alkright ?..You're Ok Mate...don't fret it !!
'Men are the same as women...just inside out !'
Logged
Men are the same as Women, just inside out !
qpan
Sr. Member
260
Activity:
0%
Thanked: 1 times
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #2 on:
23/07/2004 13:56:32 »
Well, apparently, dreams are a way of clearing useless information out of your short term and useful infomation into your long term memory. If you remember your dreams, then i suppose lots of useless stuff is also being stored in your long term memory instead of being forgotten.
Not that it really matters much, as humans on average use only 10% of their cranial capacity, so you are in no danger of overfilling your brain.
I usually wake up in the morning remembering a dream (provided i am woken by the alarm clock). But unless i write these memories down, they are forgotten very quickly! Can you still remember your dreams after a few days?
But then again, you may be going crazy (or in a few decades time, like Neil!). [:p]
"I have great faith in fools; self-confidence my friends call it."
-Edgar Allan Poe
«
Last Edit: 23/07/2004 13:58:49 by qpan
»
Logged
qazibasit
Sr. Member
344
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #3 on:
24/07/2004 10:28:21 »
well what can i say now my seniours have already told the reasons.
Logged
"There is never too late to make a change".
Exodus
Phileas Fogg
Naked Science Forum King!
1471
Activity:
0%
Geology
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #4 on:
24/07/2004 17:58:13 »
I regularly remember my dreams BUT i also need some sort of stimuli to trigger off the memory of it. When i do have dreams, they often include tidal waves or water. Repititions also occur with people in my dreams such as my girlfriend. I wouldn't worry about it at all, in fact i find remembering dreams quite interesting as some things that happen are really weird. I was shot in a dream once.
Logged
qazibasit
Sr. Member
344
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #5 on:
25/07/2004 10:56:05 »
well it is said that viewing water in dreams is a sign and prediction of a better future exodus.
Logged
"There is never too late to make a change".
jai
Full Member
64
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #6 on:
27/07/2004 10:38:00 »
i often remember dreams as well and have found that there seem to be many types.
there are the ones that are triggered by an event in real life, like the alarm going off. these are really cool, usually there is a whole story to the dream, you are in a house, a fire starts, you panic, someone starts juggling and a dog rings for the briggade, they come bell ringing and you wake to the alarm ringing. these are interesting in that they can feel like you have been dreaming for hours and have had a whole adventure but actually they happen in the space of seconds. when they have taken pictures of the brain during this period of time they found that whole sections of the brain associated with memory, logic reasoning and panic response are lighted up at once in a huge surge of energy.
then there are the dreams that are sorting and storing as qpan says. these dreams are usually not very emotional and often longer in duration. they believe that they take up to about 10 minutes in real life but again often feel much longer. there is often a sense of disassociation with them, like you are watching but not actually involved.
finally there are the dreams that seem to be used to deal with trauma. often nightmares. there are some therapists who use the dreams to help deal with the trauma, especially if the repeated nightmares are interfering with real life. quite often these are triggered by an event, such as a car accident or violence, and until the trauma is resolved often they will haunt the person for a long time. one of the ways the therapist works with these dreams is to let the person know that they create and control these dreams. that everything within them is made by the person dreaming and that they can stop it or change it as they want as soon as they realise they are dreaming.
this type of therapy works very well with children, possibly because their minds are more open? you can talk to a child and tell them that they have a magical wand that they can take to bed with them. this magic wand only works when they are asleep and it can come into their dreams with them and can change whatever they would like. remember harry potter and the wraith like things that frightened you with your own fears and were controled with laughter.?
i read a thesis once based on work with a woman who had been raped and was experiencing repeated nightmares of the rape scene. the nightmare varied in detail but always she was not in control of what was happening to her. sometimes she was watching someone else being raped, sometimes it was her, but she could never move, cry out or prevent what was happening even when she knew what was coming. the dreams became so frightening and so frequent that she was unable to sleep or to function during the day. one of the first things that the therapist said to her was that she controled the dream. the most incredible thought is that you are an architect. all of the buildings that you dream of, all of the landscapes you see, all of the amazing things you make. they are all from your imagination and they are made so easily and so effortlessly when we are asleep. that night the woman went home and she had the dream again. she was still frightened, still scared, but this time she was able to cry out. this was the first step and the frequency of the nightmares dropped. with the therapy and over time she was able to act more and more in her nightmare and subsequently she was able to act and get through what had happened to her.
back to ultima's dream, if your memory of it was very strong then it is possible that it had a lot of signifigance to you and you should think about how you felt in it and what was happening. also think about what triggered the memory of the dream, perhaps a smell or even a thought, this can be important as well. there are some elements of dreams that seem to have universal signifigance. houses and homes seem to represent your personality, your space in your head or your 'spiritual/personal' home. water usually represents emotions and usually though not always people (even ones you know) represent an aspect of yourself. dreams seem to be very self centered [
].
sorry, [:I] dreams are a pet subject of mine and i have done a lot of reading and study of the act of dreaming and interpretations of dreams. if anybody out there has a dream that they are curious about, bring it on!
and i promise not to write too much next time. sorry, i just get carried away......
yes, but.........
Logged
yaaaaay!!!!!!!
tweener
Naked Science Forum King!
1144
Activity:
0%
Thanked: 1 times
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #7 on:
28/07/2004 04:39:33 »
I have a dream I'll throw out here. It has recurred many times in my life, though usually not every night. I almost never remember the dream but everyone else does.
I dream that the wall is about to fall. I get up in the bed and start pushing on the wall to hold it up and shout for everyone to "get out of the way! The wall is falling!". Needless to say, everyone else remembers the dream quite well. Usually someone gets me settled down and I don't remember a thing, but sometimes I have a very vague memory of a wall and being very frightened.
As far as I know I've never had any experience with a wall falling or trapping me or anyone else.
----
John - The Eternal Pessimist.
Logged
----
John - The Eternal Pessimist.
jai
Full Member
64
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #8 on:
28/07/2004 10:51:26 »
O...K...? well...... the wall represents your womb link to your mother and you are eternally frightened that the aliens will come and take you again.[
].
no, seriously. let me see if i have got this right, this is a dream that you mostly dont remember and you are not emotionally involved in it (i.e. you only remember feeling frightened, you are not still frightened when you remember it). if this is the case then i can put forward two suggestions and it is possibly a combination of both. however because of this i do not think it is a dream that would warrant 'interpretation', i.e that it has deep psychological meaning. this dream does not leave you feeling the dream very strongly, you remember the sensations and your emotional responses very vividly.
the first suggestion is that it is a stress dream, that it possibly started in your childhood, you dont have to have seen a wall collapsing, maybe you heard about it (remember the football stadium incident?) or maybe you were feverish and your balance was affected so that you thought the wall was collapsing. you probably will not remember the initial incident as it was so minor. however the dream response that you had to it has become a habbit. now, when you are feeling stressed in your everyday life, like your world is collapsing around you, this dream comes back as a stress response.
the second suggestion is more about what triggers it rather than where the original images came from. when you sleep and you move from deep sleep to rem sleep (dreaming sleep) your body becomes partially paralised. there are two disorders associated with this. narcolepsy, where they believe your body drops into rem mode whilst you are awake, and another one (cant remeber the name of it)where you dont become paralised during rem and you act out your dreams. sleepwalking or talking is a very small version of this (incidentally there has been a case in america where a man got off a murder charge by saying that he had been asleep ! only in america!).
however your dream may be triggered by the fear of the feeling when you drop into rem. a lot of people will remember the falling dream, just as they are dropping off to sleep they will fall and wake up with a start. i trip over something in my dream and it wakes me up. this is thought to be a panic response to the feeling of the paralasis kicking in at the begining of rem. but when you have been cycling through deep sleep for three hours or so and then you go into rem the panic can be a lot more intense and can trigger a stronger reaction. your mind will try to find a way of explaining the panic and will produce a dream , in your case the wall is colapsing, and your body will kick out of the paralasis that it is dropping into to respond to the dream.
so, i promised i would not write so much this time and have failed. does anyone else have any other ideas or interpretations?
yes, but.........
Logged
yaaaaay!!!!!!!
tweener
Naked Science Forum King!
1144
Activity:
0%
Thanked: 1 times
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #9 on:
28/07/2004 23:18:42 »
Interesting..... The dream is definitely stress related because it only occurs when I'm under a lot of stress.
----
John - The Eternal Pessimist.
Logged
----
John - The Eternal Pessimist.
Quantumcat
The Kitty Down Under
Hero Member
894
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #10 on:
29/07/2004 04:06:02 »
wow, that sounds like a freaky dream tweener
I had a dream that was really weird. I can't remember all of it, it was a huge story, but I can only remember one scene. Somehow I am in an attic, a pretty messy dusty attic, and the black cat gives me a present, I think it's a heavy gold pocketwatch. It has pictures of people moving in the face and a face on the reverse side and strange symbols on it and it has the feeling of being a very ancient and mysterious object. The cat tells me if I look at it too much something bad will happen but he doesn't specify what. As I look at it the faces grow dimmer and dimmer and like an image going from lesser to lesser resolution. I shake it and try to get the images to come back but they are lost forever then the cat suddenly springs on me with teeth bared and eyes glowing and I get a shock like when you think you've stepped in a hole in a dream. Then the rest of the story happens. When I woke up and remembered the dream I was sure that I'd dreamed it before. Saying it in words doesn't put the kind of feelings it had in it though so it probably sounds really dumb :-P
Am I dead? Am I alive? I'm both!
Logged
tweener
Naked Science Forum King!
1144
Activity:
0%
Thanked: 1 times
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #11 on:
29/07/2004 21:39:08 »
Yours sounds pretty freaky too Quantum. It's really strange how the feelings and emotions play in dreams also. Dreams are not just images like a movie - they have wonderful colors and smells and feelings and emotions that really give them lots of dimention that just cannot be described in words.
----
John - The Eternal Pessimist.
Logged
----
John - The Eternal Pessimist.
jai
Full Member
64
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #12 on:
30/07/2004 10:25:20 »
did you know that most people dream in black and white and just remember colours in the same way that you remember the colours of lucy's dresses in 'i love lucy' if you used to watch it in black and white when you were a child (gosh, that's showing my age). therefor if you dream with very strong colours you should take note of the colours because they are supposedly important.
quantum, that is such a cool dream and it is not dumb at all. Freud would have a field day. in classic interpretation the attic would represent the place that you store old things from your past (obvious yeah!)and the cat would represent a teacher. a teacher is the part of yourself that shows you connections that are more than just pure logic, like intuition or that spooky 'knowing' feeling that you sometimes get about things.
the cat being black, (sounds like a book!)would be interpreted as meaning that you are unsure as to the motivations of the teacher. in other words you dont know if it is a 'good' or 'bad' part of yourself and you are not sure if you trust it.
the cat gives you a watch and tells you that if you look at it too much something bad will happen. the watch would be a memory, something that may not be in the surface of your mind yet but is sitting just bellow the subconscious surface. have you been feeling slightly disturbed lately but not sure why? are there questions about your past that are bugging you? something like that. but when you look at the watch, the memory it starts to fade and the cat jumps on you scaring you.
it depends on your feelings throughout the dream but this could be that when you look at things from your past, especially the scary things that you are to frightened to look at, they get more distant, they fade, and the thing that actually hurts you is not the memory or the event but the way that you deal with it now.
the cat is part of you, a part that wants you to see this thing from the past but is also frightened of it. part of you thinks that this memory should hurt you, but it is not the memory but you and your reactions to it that determine whether you are hurt by it. in other words, do not be afraid to look and to see, just be aware that your feelings about it may not be acurate, like when you feel guilt or responsibility but it was not your fault and you were not in controll.
clear as mud! [
] this is just one interpretation, it may not be accurate, i dont know you and only you will know what the dream really means. a lot of it will depend on your feelings throughout the dream.
yes, but.........
Logged
yaaaaay!!!!!!!
Quantumcat
The Kitty Down Under
Hero Member
894
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #13 on:
31/07/2004 03:30:54 »
Wow, that is so cool jai!
I had that dream ages ago, like in feburary or january ... I just remember it because I woke up thinking what a weird and cool dream. I promptly forgot it though. I think I only remember the attic scene possibly because the jolt made me wake up for a minute.
I recommend to everyone to write down your dreams when you wake up. It could be very interesting! You could even turn them into wacky short stories if you like writing but have no ideas.
I have two or three dreams that used to happen often when I was younger: there was one where I was on a flying carpet and there were bats chasing me through dark places, one where we were in a house and you had to collect all the money on the ground before it faded away, and if you were collecting money from a room where it had started fading for a long time your money in your sack would disappear too. The house was old and victorian, a heavy green colour, with lace curtains and brocade etc. There were lots of people scurrying around looking for treasure ... it had the feeling a bit of being a game show but more serious. Then there was one that's happened a few times with variations where I can fly, with a few others, and we have to escape from people who want to lock us up in a big hall with the other flying children, we end up getting captured after a long battle to escape them but I think we figure out how to escape together with the other captured children out of an old window behind one of the many crates that the bad people must have forgotten was there.
Everyone else if you have dreams you remember post them here; it's so interesting to hear other people's dreams!
Am I dead? Am I alive? I'm both!
«
Last Edit: 31/07/2004 03:32:08 by Quantumcat
»
Logged
jai
Full Member
64
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #14 on:
01/08/2004 10:53:09 »
when i was a little girl i would have a recurring dream that used to make me cry every time. it was a bit gruesome and sad. my family and i would be coming home late evening just as the light was turning blue grey. we had been away on a long trip somewhere. they would all go inside and i would follow them in a few minutes later. there were strange men in the house and they took my family. it would then cut to the bath area (i lived in a tin shed in real life and the bath area was outside, we lived in the bush so no neighbours, there was a log that we stood on with a tree next to it and shower connected to a branch on the tree. at the end of the log was another log, placed perpendicular to it, like a T, and on this we used to keep two baby baths for collecting the used water so that we could water the plants with it) The men had cut the arms and legs of my mum and dad and little brother and placed them in the babybaths and they were moving them around in a sort of ritualistic way at the end of the T like it was an alter and they were preparing for something. i knew that i was next, there was no blood but the bodies of my family were blue. i was not frightened (i had been earlier when we went into the house and the men were first there) but i was just very very sad. the men had no faces, all i could see of them were their legs and arms moving things around.[xx(]
i was eight when i first had this dream and it came back quite regularly for about 3 years. it only stopped when my mother told me her worst nightmare as a child and after i heard that i never had another nightmare, not that i remember anyway. weird huh?. her nightmare was simple but scared the living daylights out of me. it was just two images that would repeat constantly one after the other, inkblots on paper then desert landscape, inkblots then landscape and so on. even weirder!
by the way, flying dreams are supposed to be really good, if you dream that you are flying then it means that you are achieving the things that you need in your life, you are flying in life and getting where you need.
yes, but.........
Logged
yaaaaay!!!!!!!
OldMan
Sr. Member
222
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #15 on:
02/08/2004 04:57:15 »
Wow quantum I used to have a dream very similar to the flying one you describe here. I recall my flying action was very strange, I had to pedal my legs like i was riding a bike. Strange about the similarity though.
One dream that used to occur frequently when i was young was that i'd be asleep and wake up to find all these (20 or 30) black panthers around my bed which would all leap onto the bed and start attacking me. The last bit I would usually view from the other side of the room though as if it wasn't me under the writhing mass of bodies. Oddly enough after having this dream for what seemed like years it stopped one night after my brother came and saved me.
Tim
Logged
Tim
Quantumcat
The Kitty Down Under
Hero Member
894
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #16 on:
02/08/2004 22:26:24 »
Your brother saved you in your dream ... ? I bet the dream interpretists will have fun there
In my flying dream you sort of had to push off the ground with your feet then to continue flying, do a sort of breaststroke with your arms
Then you sort of glided where you wanted to go by sort of propulsing. I only remember clearly two actual places in the dream, the big dark warehouse and a starry hill where we were trying to get away from them, and some roman ruins in the distance.
What happens in your flying dream?? Can you remember the story at all?
Am I dead? Am I alive? I'm both!
Logged
jai
Full Member
64
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #17 on:
03/08/2004 03:05:56 »
so cool, i used to fly in my dreams as well, that breast stroke thing. i remember having trouble with the electrical and telegraph wires. they kept getting in the way.
yes, but.........
Logged
yaaaaay!!!!!!!
OldMan
Sr. Member
222
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #18 on:
03/08/2004 04:21:30 »
I thought the interpreters would have a field day with it as well and was interested in what they'd say but so far nothing.
I only have vague memories of the locations of the flying dream, one was my primary school but when I read what you said about escaping through the window behind the crate it brought back memories I'd completely forgotten. I know it was a dark warehouse kind of place and it was night outside but don't recall if there was a hill or roman ruins.
I remember sometimes in the dream I would have trouble contolling the height of how far I was flying but would get it under control. Otherwise there isn't a lot I can remember.
Tim
Logged
Tim
Trang
Jr. Member
18
Activity:
0%
Re: Is recalling dreams linked to mental illness?
«
Reply #19 on:
03/08/2004 10:29:51 »
Sorry to cut short, but I think many people always remember their dreams when getting up( but maybe not all the story). (and I'm is 1 of them!
)
Anyway, I think the importance is not the dreams, but the feeling after wake up, are you fine and eager to begin a new day? That's the most important!!!
Logged
Print
Pages: [
1
]
2
Go Up
« previous
next »
Tags:
There was an error while thanking
Thanking...