[neilep (OP)]

Dearest Ewe Lot,

See Hoppy ?

 [ Invalid Attachment ]

Hoppy is my ear ! (Run Hoppy Run !)

Sound travels much faster underwater yes ?...is it amplified too ?

..anyway, if sound travels a lot better underwater then why is it more difficult for Hoppy (my ear...Stop Hoppy Stop !) to hear underwater ?..ie: it's loud but not clear !

Why's that then ?

Thanks


Neil
Ear Owner
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[rosalind dna]

Hi Neil
You have posted similar threads on TNS recently.

http://www.thenakedscientists.com/forum/index.php?topic=16642.0
http://www.thenakedscientists.com/forum/index.php?topic=12241.0

This thread from 24/08/08 is very similar in it's topic/theme to this one asking about:  What Would Happen To My Ear If Left Indefinitely In Water ?

http://www.thenakedscientists.com/forum/index.php?topic=16642.0


Yes hearing is amplified underwater because the normal gravity is amplified.

[Karen W.]

I would think the water puts pressure on the eardrum and perhaps stops the sound from bouncing off the drum as easily as it would normally without water causing less vibration in the ear and muffling the sound instead.. that doesn't mean it doesn't travel fast through the water.. but perhaps the water barricades the drum some..

Just a guess.. lets see if I am anywhere near close the answer.. LOL

[neilep (OP)]

Hi Neil
You have posted similar threads on TNS recently.

http://www.thenakedscientists.com/forum/index.php?topic=16642.0
http://www.thenakedscientists.com/forum/index.php?topic=12241.0

This thread from 24/08/08 is very similar in it's topic/theme to this one asking about:  What Would Happen To My Ear If Left Indefinitely In Water ?

http://www.thenakedscientists.com/forum/index.php?topic=16642.0


Yes hearing is amplified underwater because the normal gravity is amplified.

Thank Ewe Rosalind. And I really appreciate the links to other ear related threads that I have asked. I am pleased that in this case I have not just repeated my questions , but have in fact asked a completely different question specifically regarding hearing underwater.

Though, I had to use my Rabbit ear piccy again because it's so cute. Though, I do get strange looks when doing the school run and pick the children up with a carrot sticking out of my ear !!   []

[neilep (OP)]

I would think the water puts pressure on the eardrum and perhaps stops the sound from bouncing off the drum as easily as it would normally without water causing less vibration in the ear and muffling the sound instead.. that doesn't mean it doesn't travel fast through the water.. but perhaps the water barricades the drum some..

Just a guess.. lets see if I am anywhere near close the answer.. LOL

Thank ewe Karen.

Do ewe think this means that the eardrum is also completely submerged in water then ?

[Karen W.]

I was assuming you meant if your ear was under water and completely submerged,when the sound was being made.. Is that what you meant? Or did you mean with your ear out would you hear the noise louder because the noise was traveling through the water?

[neilep (OP)]

I was assuming you meant if your ear was under water and completely submerged,when the sound was being made.. Is that what you meant? Or did you mean with your ear out would you hear the noise louder because the noise was traveling through the water?

yes, I did mean that Hoppy would be totally submerged...I was  wondering if air pressure protected the ear drum from being submerged too and thus was wondering why the sound was muffled !

sorry..not good at explaining !

[Karen W.]

Air pressure? I don't understand how air pressure could prevent the eardrum from being submerged??I would think your head would be weighty enough to submerge the eardrum .. LOl I think I am still confused,, Hee hee,,

Not water pressure?

[neilep (OP)]

I mean the air would as act a physical barrier to the water.....

..oh...lets just say I am even more tired than ewe !... []

[Karen W.]

I know what you mean now.. I think.. like say your ear was a cup.. and you set the cup inverted straight down into the water would the air trapped in the ear act as a barrier to the drum then? That might make sense if your ear is set straight into the water ear side down.. and not back of head down and ear filled with water and air displaced! Right?

[RD]

then why is it more difficult for Hoppy (my ear...Stop Hoppy Stop !) to hear underwater ?..ie: it's loud but not clear

Underwater sound is "not clear" because frequency dependent attenuation causes high frequency sounds to be absorbed much more than the low frequency sounds.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attenuation

[blakestyger]

Are both your ears mounted at that rakish angle?
What caused it - childhood encounter with railings?
Were the fire brigade really that rough?

 []

[lyner]

Your ears are specially developed to extract the very last bit of energy from the sound that you hear in air. This is achieved by 'matching' the impedance of the air (a very low density medium) to the medium in your cochlea which is more dense. Basically, the air is a low impedance medium - it carries the energy in waves with lowish pressure vibrations and relatively great movement of the particles. In a liquid, the same energy level consists of larger pressure variations and much less movement (it is pretty much incompressible). The drum starts the process and the tiny bones (ossicles) act like levers to achieve the matching, reducing the movement and increasing the force.

If your ear is under water the medium has high impedance and the ear's mechanism only serves to reduce the movement even further. You would be better off without all that Nature's Technology!

From memory, I think I have 'heard' sounds through the base of my neck rather than through my ears. Well, it felt like it.

btw, Ignore the ribald remarks. Even the dung beetle's mother thinks it is beautiful.

[neilep (OP)]

then why is it more difficult for Hoppy (my ear...Stop Hoppy Stop !) to hear underwater ?..ie: it's loud but not clear

Underwater sound is "not clear" because frequency dependent attenuation causes high frequency sounds to be absorbed much more than the low frequency sounds.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attenuation

Many Thanks RD..this is very helpful.

[neilep (OP)]

Are both your ears mounted at that rakish angle?
What caused it - childhood encounter with railings?
Were the fire brigade really that rough?

 []

Yes...they abused my ears !..the damned ear abusers !!

[neilep (OP)]

Your ears are specially developed to extract the very last bit of energy from the sound that you hear in air. This is achieved by 'matching' the impedance of the air (a very low density medium) to the medium in your cochlea which is more dense. Basically, the air is a low impedance medium - it carries the energy in waves with lowish pressure vibrations and relatively great movement of the particles. In a liquid, the same energy level consists of larger pressure variations and much less movement (it is pretty much incompressible). The drum starts the process and the tiny bones (ossicles) act like levers to achieve the matching, reducing the movement and increasing the force.

If your ear is under water the medium has high impedance and the ear's mechanism only serves to reduce the movement even further. You would be better off without all that Nature's Technology!

From memory, I think I have 'heard' sounds through the base of my neck rather than through my ears. Well, it felt like it.

btw, Ignore the ribald remarks. Even the dung beetle's mother thinks it is beautiful.

I think Dung beetles are very pretty too !

Thank ewe Sophiecentaur.

This is fascinating and I actually understand it !.. *falls over in disbelief*


Thanks to Everybody for their helpful and insightful answers !

[rosalind dna]

Neil this is what the DUNG BEETLE use for their dens and food
as this YouTube clip shows:  (YUK)

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=I1RHmSm36aE

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dung_beetle

[lyner]

Thanks to Everybody for their helpful and insightful answers !

I thought they were inhearingfull answers, actually.

[Make it Lady]

'ear 'ear!

[rosalind dna]

'ear 'ear!

LOL LOL LOL