No, he is just restating reply #3.

Alan please think about what I am asking with some genuine interest and thought and not just reply based on your knowledge. I know you are not stupid and have a good mind, I would really appreciate your own input without the knowledge you recall.

Let us discuss an analogy,

Let us take A and B divided by a length of space.

We can imagine a train track and both observers are standing on the same track a length apart.

r=X

A...................................................................B

It is daylight , (A) can see (B) and (B) can see (A)

(B) moves away from (A) while (A) remains in a fixed position,

A..................................................................→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→→B

Can you or anybody please describe in your own words what (A) observes of (B) as (B) moves way?

[attachment=20947]

This is NOT a new theory , it is a discussion between us, if we make a new theory by the end between us, that is another story.