0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
Quote from: Bored chemist on 04/08/2009 19:35:16The old adage that you should feed a fever... I thought it was starve a fever, feed a cold?
The old adage that you should feed a fever...
Quote from: Simpleton on 04/08/2009 22:51:37QuotePeople have, it hasn't shown to be make any difference, therefore it stays as it is.Do you have a citation for that, interesting.http://www.evitamins.com/healthnotes.asp?ContentID=2126009Its has a 1 star rating "For an herb, supported by traditional use but minimal or no scientific evidence. For a supplement, little scientific support and/or minimal health benefit.""According to obscure sources, lomatium is reputed to have antiviral effects. One source suggests the constituents tetronic acids and a glucoside of luteolin may be potentially antiviral.2 However, little is known about how these compounds act or if other ones might be as important."Thats from a site that would be biased on the side on benefit.I could, I expect find more studies or reports.What do you think happens? That herbs are investigated but then dismissed? Far from it. The drug companies are always looking for new plants herbs or remedies to studies and asses the structure of, and then test to see if they actually have any benefit. OP means original post or poster.
QuotePeople have, it hasn't shown to be make any difference, therefore it stays as it is.Do you have a citation for that, interesting.
People have, it hasn't shown to be make any difference, therefore it stays as it is.
"How difficult would it be for the medical advice to read. "drink plenty of fluids containing tincture a, b, c and stay in bed."
It would be easy; and dishonest.
Unless there were some real evidence that a, b, and c worked. If there is, then name a, b and c; otherwise accept that you don't have much to offer.
It's fair to say that the virus may mutate and become more of a problem. It's equally likely (statistically) that it will mutate and become less of a problem. It is in the interests of the virus (if you will forgive the anthropomorphism) to become less of a problem.
Why does averyone seem to fixate on the idea that "it will get worse"; it might or it might not.
" Bet you'd consider eye of newt or tongue of bat over hula hoops! " No I wouldn't I don't believe in magic but I do believe in evidence. Food is known to help snake oil isn't.
"Before they become desperate it would be nice if they had a few more realistic options, even if they have not being billion dollar tested." There are at least 3 antivirals used; one (amantidine) is a bit crap (but I'd choose it rather than eye of newt) and the third is largely being kept in reserve for exactly the reasons you talk about.
Did you not realise that the people doing the planning can read wiki too? They have heard of resistance. Incidentally, do you know that plenty of drugs are based on botanicals?
It will be there along with things like comfrey - known as "knitbone" because of its supposed healing properties and actually found to be hepatotoxic and carcinogenic.
The stuff that doesn't work, or has been shown not to have any real effect, thats called complementary medicine, or maybe just plants.
I think the general issue with considering complementary therapies is to attempt to consider the mechanism through which it works. Setting aside placebo (which is an incredibly powerful effect), this should give you an indication of whether or not there's likely to be any as yet undiscovered physiological effect. By this regime, herbal treatment (which may well include beneficial chemicals) shows a great deal more promise than homeopathy, and one is forced to question things like acupuncture (from what I recall, the most recent studies showed acupuncture works just as well with blunt wooden needles). Not setting aside placebo, you're in a whole different ballpark...
Quote from: Variola on 04/08/2009 22:44:40 The stuff that doesn't work, or has been shown not to have any real effect, thats called complementary medicine, or maybe just plants. Any real effect...even with some effect, perhaps it is better, for some people, than no effect at all.
Well, the idea that people are being sold a bunch of pretty flowers on the false grounds that it cures illness is straightforward fraud
...the idea that people are being sold a bunch of pretty flowers on the false grounds that it cures illness is straightforward fraud.
The other thing is that you really shouldn't mix drugs with other xenobiotics.
Are you aware of one noted side effect of St John's wort?
one woman has become pregnant as a result of the "remedy" messing with metabolism
How sure are you that these "harmless herbal remedies" won't screw up the effects of really effective antivirals like tamiflu?
Unless you can show that these potions are not actively counterproductive I don't think it's morrally correct to promote their use.
Hope that clears up some of the myths in the UK about herbs and combining herbs for medicinal purposes.
Either your lack of knowledge or experience regarding herbs and their ability to heal, is very limited, or you just want to put your head back in the sand, and hope that it will all go away.
..sounds like the start of a Daily Mirror story! Come on!
Be careful, this thread is starting to look like spam.QuoteHope that clears up some of the myths in the UK about herbs and combining herbs for medicinal purposes.Nope. All you've done is said that you can get herbal tea in Germany that claims to help against colds and flu. You can get herbal tea pretty much anywhere, but that doesn't mean anything about it's effectiveness or how it interacts with other chemicals.
you can get herbal tea in Germany
You are ignoring the very fact that the whole industry is unlicensed and unregulated.
Spam? Thanks! Actually I would call it intelligent argument, but I am biased!
Quote from: Simpleton on 07/08/2009 13:09:46Spam? Thanks! Actually I would call it intelligent argument, but I am biased!Not a compliment, I'm afraid - the links to websites and detailed product details make it look like you're selling things.
People have died because of alternative/eastern medicine practitioners persuading them to refuse conventional medicine. Some have often paid thousand and thousands of pounds to be treated with plants and conned into believing that it will beat their cancer.That is plain outrageous, and I feel very strongly about it. You are ignoring the very fact that the whole industry is unlicensed and unregulated.
The contraceptive pill packets now coming with a warning not to take St Johns wort due to the effects it has on the hormonal balance and the pill.I have yet to see a similar warning on packets of St Johns wort.
If you want to promote the virtues of herbal remedies then go ahead, but get your facts straight first.Also explain how these remedies can be of so much of a benefit when advice difference wildy from one practitioner to another, and how, if these things are so great, can someone set themselves up as a herbalist/homeopath with no formal training or qualifications? Oh yes I know there are some available, but people don't have to have them.Unlike doctors, microbiologists, biochemists etc who train for years only to be told by some plant lovers that they are depriving ill people and that we are all 'scared'!!I means, FFS! []
Quote from: BenV on 07/08/2009 13:43:04Quote from: Simpleton on 07/08/2009 13:09:46Spam? Thanks! Actually I would call it intelligent argument, but I am biased!Not a compliment, I'm afraid - the links to websites and detailed product details make it look like you're selling things.Indeed. Why else would the poster persist in trying to push the alternative remedy when the original post was apparently a curious one?
No-one until this point has anything good to say about herbs, roots, fruits etc. Shame really, as there really are some very intelligent people commenting within this forum. Perhaps I came through the wrong door... Left - Conventional medicine, Right - All others...
Quote from: Simpleton on 07/08/2009 14:16:42 No-one until this point has anything good to say about herbs, roots, fruits etc. Shame really, as there really are some very intelligent people commenting within this forum. Perhaps I came through the wrong door... Left - Conventional medicine, Right - All others...
I wouldn't say that's true - we've acknowledged that many conventional medicines are derived from botanicals, but expressed a healthy concern as to the promotion of unquantified, untested (officially) 'folk' remedies.
I'm not sure how these things are promoted in Germany - maybe that's the root of our concern - I've seen herbal teas advertised as a cure for HIV/AIDS, and that's very worrying.
I'd be interested to hear more about the regulation of the industry in Germany - do you know what one would have to do to get a PZN number for a product? What are the regulations on complementary therapies there? What tests do they need to pass? What qualifications does one need to be a therapist?
I'm a little confused by the way you mention homeopathy/homeopaths alongside herbalism - surely they're an entirely different kettle of fish?
...can someone set themselves up as a herbalist/homeopath with no formal training or qualifications?