Waterproof Hanky

30 September 2007




A glassA glass
A hankerchiefA hankerchief or a thin piece of fabric
TapSome water




  1. Fill the glass up with water
  2. Stretch the fabric over the top of the glass
  3. Turn the glass upside down, over someone else's head if you dare...


Stretching the Hankey over the glass


Rather surprisingly you should find that the water stays in the glass even though you wouldn't think the handkerchief was very waterproof.

Glass upsidedown


The first thing to work out is how water falls out of a glass normally. For the water to fall out something has to take its place, normally air. But how does the air choose where to get into the glass.

If the base of the water is uneven, a lower part will have more weight of water above it than a higher part. This means it will start to fall down sucking water away from other areas, and that the air can get into the higher areas, allowing the water to fall out.


Water falling out of a glass 1Water falling out of a glass 2
If one part of the water is slightly lower than the other it will have more weight of water above it.This means that the lower side moves downwards which means it has yet more weight above it, so in one place the water goes down and another up.


This can happen because there is nothing stopping the slight unevenness in the base of the water growing.

If you look at a hanky it has lots of fine pieces of cotton thread woven into a fabric.  In between them there are small holes where normally air or water can get through. Cotton really likes water so once the hanky is wet it is covered with water. Now if air wants to get through the holes it has to push the water out of the way - it has to blow little bubbles.

If you have ever tried blowing bubbles and then stopped halfway through you will know that the film will try and pull itself flat due to the surface tension. The same happens here, but the smaller the bubble the harder they will pull back, and there is no soap in the water which reduces the surface tension.  


Blowing a BubbleMicroscopic view
If you blow a bubble the soap film pushes back due to surface tension.In the same way trying to blow bubbles through the hanky will mean surface tension will push back.


This means that the air has to push really quite hard to get through the fabric, much harder than it could do randomly.  So the imperfections can't build up and the water stays inside.

The Waterproof Hankey

 The hanky isn't watertight, but it is airtight, which is enough to keep the water in.

If you put the glass on its side or make the hanky very loose there is enough pressure difference to blow the bubbles, letting air in so it will leak.

A loose hankey


What has this got to do with breathable fabrics?


In a breathable coat (made of something like Gore-Tex(TM)) you want to stop rain coming in but still let sweat evaporate from your skin. This is the opposite requirement from the hanky which lets liquid through but not gasses. The problem is actually solved in a really similar way.

Instead of making the fabric out of something like cotton which loves water, you make it out of something which hates it (like PTFE - the non-stick frying pan stuff). Now for a water drop to go through it has to split up into lots of tiny drops, which surface tension will fight very strongly just like making small bubbles, but water vapour from your sweat can pass straight through. Just what you wanted.

A breathable membrane


Add a comment